{
  "_note": "The facts lane's reading of every sentence Access Routes prints about a rule, copied from the reader's file (made 2026-11-14T19:18:22Z) with its rows, verdicts, words and quotations unchanged. Left out: each passage's local file name, fetch address and date note, the citations as the design printed them (the page's citations are in routes.json), and any field naming a date the site's boundary-date test keeps out of committed data (listed in `left_out`). A sentence prints only where a row here supports that exact string: its `printed_form` with `printed_form_verdict` SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN, its `sentence` with `verdict` SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN, or its `words_if_changed` with `verdict` SUPPORTED WITH OTHER WORDS. `rules_in_their_words` are the quotations part 3 prints, each under its `printed_label` where the reader supports one, else its `label`.",
  "schema_version": 1,
  "data_source": "scrutica-access-routes-rules-read",
  "is_estimated": false,
  "made_by": "claude-opus-5-5 (reader), 14 Nov 2026",
  "made_at": "2026-11-14T19:18:22Z",
  "how": "Every quotation was cut by tools/quotes.py from the saved source (whitespace collapsed), never typed, except the 2009 advisory opinion's sentence, read from the page image; two conversion artefacts are corrected and noted on their rows.",
  "second_reading": {
    "made_by": "claude-opus-5-5 (second reader), 16 Nov 2026",
    "made_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
    "how": "Read against the released text of RIN 0694-AK50 (bis.gov PDF, sha256 8329860e901198e9…, as its pdftotext output rin-0694-ak50.txt). Every quotation and passage from the released text was cut by work/cut.py (start and end phrases inside a line window; lines joined, page-number lines dropped, whitespace collapsed) from the second reader's specs (work/reader-a/spec.json, spec2.json; outputs cuts.json, cuts2.json), never typed; each of the builder's 13 copies was compared with the cut character for character, and all 13 were equal. The eCFR § 744.23(a) lead-in was cut from the fetched XML (work/ecfr/sec-744.23.xml), tags stripped and whitespace collapsed. Passages of the 2025 policy statement and of H.R. 2683 are the first reader's cuts, not reopened. The first reader's rows, made_by and made_at are unchanged; the second reader added 7 sentence rows, 13 quotation rows and a dated label with its verdict on 9 rows, and recounted verdict_counts.",
    "rows": {
      "sentences": [
        "lede-2-renting",
        "lede-3-unpublished",
        "lede-3-in-force",
        "rented-catch-all",
        "rented-on-publication",
        "rented-in-force",
        "tick-in-force-rented"
      ],
      "rules_in_their_words": [
        "rule-rented-6",
        "rule-rented-7",
        "rule-rented-8",
        "rule-rented-9",
        "rule-rented-10",
        "rule-rented-11",
        "rule-rented-12",
        "rule-sold-6",
        "rule-sold-7",
        "rule-moved-3",
        "rule-moved-4",
        "rule-bought-5",
        "rule-bought-6"
      ],
      "dated_labels": [
        "rule-sold-1",
        "rule-moved-1",
        "rule-sold-2",
        "rule-sold-3",
        "rule-rented-1",
        "rule-rented-2",
        "rule-rented-3",
        "rule-rented-5",
        "rule-bought-4"
      ]
    },
    "verdicts": {
      "sentences": {
        "SUPPORTED WITH OTHER WORDS": 2,
        "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN": 5
      },
      "rules_in_their_words": {
        "QUOTED EXACTLY": 13
      },
      "dated_labels": {
        "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN": 9
      }
    },
    "report": "planning/research-outputs/remote-access-rule-2026-11/reports/reader-a.md"
  },
  "verdict_counts": {
    "SUPPORTED WITH OTHER WORDS": 8,
    "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN": 14
  },
  "sentences": [
    {
      "id": "lede-1",
      "sentence": "Selling a controlled AI chip to a company headquartered in China needs a US licence, wherever the buyer is.",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED WITH OTHER WORDS",
      "words_if_changed": "Exporting a controlled AI chip to a company headquartered in China needs a US licence, wherever the buyer is.",
      "quotation": "The Department of Commerce, Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) is issuing this guidance to clarify that a license is required to export advanced computing items to entities headquartered in Country Group D:5 (see supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the Export Administration Regulations (EAR) (15 CFR parts 730-774)) or Macau or with an ultimate parent company headquartered in Country Group D:5 or Macau – even if the entities themselves are located outside Country Group D:5 or Macau.",
      "section": "BIS guidance of 31 May 2026, para. 1",
      "document_date": "2026-05-31",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/bis-guidance-may-31-2026.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:38Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "lede, B and L first screens",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "guidance-s1",
          "quotation": "The Department of Commerce, Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) is issuing this guidance to clarify that a license is required to export advanced computing items to entities headquartered in Country Group D:5 (see supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the Export Administration Regulations (EAR) (15 CFR parts 730-774)) or Macau or with an ultimate parent company headquartered in Country Group D:5 or Macau – even if the entities themselves are located outside Country Group D:5 or Macau.",
          "section": "BIS guidance of 31 May 2026, para. 1",
          "source": "BIS, Guidance Regarding Enforcement of License Requirements for Advanced Computing Items for Entities Headquartered in Country Group D:5 and Macau [May 31, 2026]",
          "document_date": "2026-05-31",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/bis-guidance-may-31-2026.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:38Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "guidance-742",
          "quotation": "Specifically, a license requirement continues to apply under § 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A) of the EAR to all destinations outside the United States for these advanced computing items when such items are for entities headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, Country Group D:5 or Macau.",
          "section": "BIS guidance of 31 May 2026, para. 3",
          "source": "BIS, Guidance Regarding Enforcement of License Requirements for Advanced Computing Items for Entities Headquartered in Country Group D:5 and Macau [May 31, 2026]",
          "document_date": "2026-05-31",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/bis-guidance-may-31-2026.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:38Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "742.6-a6iiiA",
          "quotation": "(iii)(A) Worldwide license requirement. A license is required to export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) items specified in ECCNs 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a; 3A090.a; 3D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, or 3A090.a); 3E001 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, or 3A090.a); 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a; 4A004.z.1; 4A005.z.1; 4A090.a; 4D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, and 4A005.z.1); 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090.a); 4E001 (for commodities controlled by 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, 4A005.z.1, 4A090.a or “software” specified by 4D001 (for 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, or 4A005.z.1), or 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090.a)); 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a; 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a; 5A992.z.1; 5D002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a, z.6.a, z.7.a, z.8.a, and z.9.a; 5D992.z.1; 5E002 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a or 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a or “software” specified by 5D002 (for 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a or 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a commodities)); or 5E992 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A992.z.1 or “software” controlled by 5D992.z.1.) to or within any destination worldwide.",
          "section": "15 CFR 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A)",
          "source": "15 CFR 742.6, Regional stability (eCFR)",
          "document_date": "2026-07-23",
          "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-742/section-742.6",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:47Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "744.23-a3iA",
          "quotation": "(3) Advanced computing items. (i)(A) Any item subject to the EAR and specified in ECCN 3A001.z.1.b, z.2.b, z.3.b, z.4.b; 3A090.b; 4A003.z.1.b, z.2.b; 4A004.z.2; 4A005.z.2; 4A090.b; 5A002.z.1.b, z.2.b, z.3.b, z.4.b, z.5.b; 5A004.z.1.b, z.2.b; 5A992.z.2, 5D002.z.1.b, z.2.b, z.3.b, z.4.b, z.5.b, z.6.b, z.7.b, z.8.b, and z.9.b; 5D992.z.2 destined to any destination other than those specified in Country Groups D:1, D:4, or D:5 (excluding any destination also specified in Country Groups A:5 or A:6) for an entity that is headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, either Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5 (e.g., a PRC-headquartered cloud or data server provider located outside of Country Groups D:1, D:4, or D:5 (excluding any destination also specified in Country Groups A:5 or A:6)).",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.23(a)(3)(i)(A)",
          "source": "15 CFR 744.23 (eCFR)",
          "document_date": "2026-01-15",
          "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-744/section-744.23",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "fr2026-hq",
          "quotation": "For exports to entities that are headquartered or have a parent company headquartered in Macau or a destination in Country Group D:5, including end-users located outside of destinations in Country Group D:5 or Macau, the licensing policy is a presumption of denial.",
          "section": "91 FR 1684, section II",
          "source": "91 FR 1684, FR Doc. 2026-00789 (final rule)",
          "document_date": "2026-01-15",
          "url": "https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/01/15/2026-00789/revision-to-license-review-policy-for-advanced-computing-commodities",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:57:56Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "The requirement attaches to exports, reexports and in-country transfers, that is, to \"all destinations outside the United States\" (BIS, 31 May 2026). \"Wherever the buyer is\" after \"Selling\" also covers a buyer inside the United States, where a sale is none of those and needs no licence. BIS's own plain summary uses \"export\", which keeps the sentence to its scope at the same length. For chips below 3A090.a (the .b band) the licence turns on the exporter's \"knowledge\" that the buyer is such an entity (15 CFR 744.23(a)); BIS also names a licence exception that can apply (guidance: \"unless a license exception specified in § 740.2(a)(9)(ii) is available\"). \"Headquartered in China\" is the rule's \"headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in\" D:5 (which includes China) or Macau; the dashed line's \"its parent\" carries the second half.",
      "printed_form": "Exporting a controlled AI chip to a company headquartered in China needs a US licence, wherever the buyer is.",
      "printed_form_verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN",
      "printed_form_passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "guidance-s1",
          "quotation": "The Department of Commerce, Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) is issuing this guidance to clarify that a license is required to export advanced computing items to entities headquartered in Country Group D:5 (see supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the Export Administration Regulations (EAR) (15 CFR parts 730-774)) or Macau or with an ultimate parent company headquartered in Country Group D:5 or Macau – even if the entities themselves are located outside Country Group D:5 or Macau.",
          "section": "BIS guidance of 31 May 2026, para. 1",
          "source": "BIS, Guidance Regarding Enforcement of License Requirements for Advanced Computing Items for Entities Headquartered in Country Group D:5 and Macau [May 31, 2026]",
          "document_date": "2026-05-31",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/bis-guidance-may-31-2026.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:38Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "guidance-742",
          "quotation": "Specifically, a license requirement continues to apply under § 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A) of the EAR to all destinations outside the United States for these advanced computing items when such items are for entities headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, Country Group D:5 or Macau.",
          "section": "BIS guidance of 31 May 2026, para. 3",
          "source": "BIS, Guidance Regarding Enforcement of License Requirements for Advanced Computing Items for Entities Headquartered in Country Group D:5 and Macau [May 31, 2026]",
          "document_date": "2026-05-31",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/bis-guidance-may-31-2026.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:38Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "printed_form_note": "The reader's own wording, adopted by the review as written.",
      "source": "BIS, Guidance Regarding Enforcement of License Requirements for Advanced Computing Items for Entities Headquartered in Country Group D:5 and Macau [May 31, 2026]"
    },
    {
      "id": "lede-2",
      "sentence": "Renting that company time on the same chip in a data centre abroad needs none, unless the supplier knows the work serves a weapons or military-intelligence use.",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED WITH OTHER WORDS",
      "words_if_changed": "Renting that company time on the same chip in a data centre abroad needs none, unless the supplier knows the model serves a WMD or military-intelligence use.",
      "quotation": "The following activities may trigger a license requirement under the catch-all controls of part 744 of the EAR when there is “knowledge” (see inset below for further information about “knowledge” under the EAR) that the AI model will be used for a WMD or military-intelligence end use/user:",
      "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1",
      "document_date": "2025-05-13",
      "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "lede, B and L first screens",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "ao2009",
          "quotation": "The service of providing computational capacity would not be subject to the EAR as the service provider is not shipping or transmitting any commodity, software, or technology to the user.",
          "section": "BIS Advisory Opinion, 13 Jan 2009, p. 2, answer (1)",
          "source": "BIS Advisory Opinion of 13 Jan 2009 on grid and cloud computing services (scanned letter)",
          "document_date": "2009-01-13",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/1343",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:35Z",
          "authority_tier": 1,
          "note": "read from the page image of p. 2 (rendered from the saved PDF); the PDF's character-recognition layer prints \"thc\", \"scrvicc\" and \"uscr\" for \"the\", \"service\" and \"user\""
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-lead",
          "quotation": "The following activities may trigger a license requirement under the catch-all controls of part 744 of the EAR when there is “knowledge” (see inset below for further information about “knowledge” under the EAR) that the AI model will be used for a WMD or military-intelligence end use/user:",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-transfer",
          "quotation": "Transfers (in-country), defined as a change in end use or end user, of advanced computing ICs and commodities subject to the EAR already in the possession of parties such as IaaS providers, if there is “knowledge” that the items will be used by the transferee to train AI models for or on behalf of parties headquartered in D:5 countries (including China) or Macau.",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1, second bullet",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "744.22-a",
          "quotation": "you may not export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) any item subject to the EAR without a license from BIS if, at the time of the export, reexport, or transfer (in-country), you have “knowledge” that the item is intended, entirely or in part, for a 'military-intelligence end use' in Belarus, Burma, Cambodia, the People's Republic of China (China), Russia, or Venezuela; or a country listed in Country Groups E:1 or E:2 (see supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the EAR), or for a Belarusian, Burmese, Cambodian, Chinese, Russian, or Venezuelan 'military-intelligence end user' or a 'military-intelligence end user' of a country listed in Country Group E:1 or E:2, wherever located.",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.22(a)",
          "source": "15 CFR 744.22, military-intelligence end uses or end users (eCFR)",
          "document_date": null,
          "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-744/section-744.22",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:04:12Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "fr2023-iaas",
          "quotation": "BIS is also concerned regarding the potential for China to use IaaS solutions to undermine the effectiveness of the October 7 IFR controls and continues to evaluate how it may approach this through a regulatory response.",
          "section": "88 FR 73458, response to comments on IaaS",
          "source": "88 FR 73458, FR Doc. 2023-23055 (interim final rule)",
          "document_date": "2023-10-25",
          "url": "https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/10/25/2023-23055/implementation-of-additional-export-controls-certain-advanced-computing-items-supercomputer-and",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:57:54Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Two words go beyond the source. \"Weapons\" is wider than the statement's \"WMD\" (weapons of mass destruction): a conventional-weapons use is not in it. \"The work serves\" is the statement's \"the AI model will be used for\". The statement says these activities \"may trigger\" a licence requirement under part 744's catch-all controls; the catch-alls themselves (e.g. 744.22(a)) require a licence when the knowledge exists, so on my reading (tier 4) \"needs none, unless\" does not overstate it. \"None\" otherwise rests on the 2009 advisory opinion (service not subject to the EAR), which the 2025 statement updates rather than withdraws, and on the absence of any BIS rule on remote access: Federal Register API full-text searches of BIS rules published from 1 May 2025, one for \"remote access\" and one for IaaS, each returned only 91 FR 1684 (whose remote-access terms are conditions on licences to China); the three BIS documents published 1 to 14 Nov 2026 concern other matters by their titles. If the page spells out WMD, \"weapons of mass destruction\" adds three words.",
      "printed_form": "Renting that company time on the same chip in a data centre abroad does not need one, unless the provider knows the AI model will be used for weapons of mass destruction or military intelligence.",
      "printed_form_verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN",
      "printed_form_passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-lead",
          "quotation": "The following activities may trigger a license requirement under the catch-all controls of part 744 of the EAR when there is “knowledge” (see inset below for further information about “knowledge” under the EAR) that the AI model will be used for a WMD or military-intelligence end use/user:",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-transfer",
          "quotation": "Transfers (in-country), defined as a change in end use or end user, of advanced computing ICs and commodities subject to the EAR already in the possession of parties such as IaaS providers, if there is “knowledge” that the items will be used by the transferee to train AI models for or on behalf of parties headquartered in D:5 countries (including China) or Macau.",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1, second bullet",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-wmd",
          "quotation": "Specifically, BIS has determined that access to advanced computing integrated circuits (ICs) and commodities subject to the EAR for training AI models has the potential to enable military-intelligence and weapons of mass destruction (WMD) end uses in Country Group D:5 countries (including China) or Macau.",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1, first paragraph",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "744.22-a",
          "quotation": "you may not export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) any item subject to the EAR without a license from BIS if, at the time of the export, reexport, or transfer (in-country), you have “knowledge” that the item is intended, entirely or in part, for a 'military-intelligence end use' in Belarus, Burma, Cambodia, the People's Republic of China (China), Russia, or Venezuela; or a country listed in Country Groups E:1 or E:2 (see supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the EAR), or for a Belarusian, Burmese, Cambodian, Chinese, Russian, or Venezuelan 'military-intelligence end user' or a 'military-intelligence end user' of a country listed in Country Group E:1 or E:2, wherever located.",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.22(a)",
          "source": "15 CFR 744.22, military-intelligence end uses or end users (eCFR)",
          "document_date": null,
          "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-744/section-744.22",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:04:12Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "ao2009",
          "quotation": "The service of providing computational capacity would not be subject to the EAR as the service provider is not shipping or transmitting any commodity, software, or technology to the user.",
          "section": "BIS Advisory Opinion, 13 Jan 2009, p. 2, answer (1)",
          "source": "BIS Advisory Opinion of 13 Jan 2009 on grid and cloud computing services (scanned letter)",
          "document_date": "2009-01-13",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/1343",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:35Z",
          "authority_tier": 1,
          "note": "read from the page image of p. 2 (rendered from the saved PDF); the PDF's character-recognition layer prints \"thc\", \"scrvicc\" and \"uscr\" for \"the\", \"service\" and \"user\""
        }
      ],
      "printed_form_note": "\"Provider\": for renting, the knowing party is the one holding the chips. The second bullet reaches chips \"already in the possession of parties such as IaaS providers\" when they change end user, so \"the provider\" is the statement's IaaS provider. (The first bullet puts the knowledge on whoever exports the chips to the provider, and the third on any US person who supports the training; both concern other acts than the rental.) \"Weapons of mass destruction\" is the statement's own expansion of WMD (its first paragraph, quoted below). \"Will be used for … military intelligence\" renders \"will be used for a WMD or military-intelligence end use/user\". \"Does not need one, unless … knows\" against \"may trigger a license requirement … when there is “knowledge”\": read strictly, \"unless\" makes knowledge a necessary condition, which is what the statement says; the catch-all it invokes (e.g. 744.22(a)) requires a licence when the knowledge exists, so on my reading (tier 4) the sentence does not overstate it. \"The AI model\" follows the 13 May 2025 file; the file bis.gov serves today prints \"SI model\".",
      "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)"
    },
    {
      "id": "sold-today",
      "sentence": "Needs a licence; case by case below a performance line.",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN",
      "words_if_changed": null,
      "quotation": "There is a case-by-case license review policy for license applications for exports of commodities with a TPP (as defined in Technical Note 2 to 3A090.a and 3A090.b) less than 21,000, and a 'total DRAM bandwidth' (as defined in the notes to paragraph (dd)(1) in supplement no. 2 to part 748) less than 6,500 GB/s, when destined to end-users located in China or Macau, provided the applicant provides the additional information described in supplement no. 2 to part 748 under paragraph (dd).",
      "section": "15 CFR 742.6(b)(10)(iii)(A)(1), first sentence",
      "document_date": "2026-07-23",
      "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-742/section-742.6",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:47Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "sold route, B (right end) and L (right column)",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "742.6-a6iiiA",
          "quotation": "(iii)(A) Worldwide license requirement. A license is required to export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) items specified in ECCNs 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a; 3A090.a; 3D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, or 3A090.a); 3E001 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, or 3A090.a); 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a; 4A004.z.1; 4A005.z.1; 4A090.a; 4D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, and 4A005.z.1); 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090.a); 4E001 (for commodities controlled by 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, 4A005.z.1, 4A090.a or “software” specified by 4D001 (for 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, or 4A005.z.1), or 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090.a)); 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a; 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a; 5A992.z.1; 5D002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a, z.6.a, z.7.a, z.8.a, and z.9.a; 5D992.z.1; 5E002 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a or 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a or “software” specified by 5D002 (for 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a or 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a commodities)); or 5E992 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A992.z.1 or “software” controlled by 5D992.z.1.) to or within any destination worldwide.",
          "section": "15 CFR 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A)",
          "source": "15 CFR 742.6, Regional stability (eCFR)",
          "document_date": "2026-07-23",
          "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-742/section-742.6",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:47Z",
          "authority_tier": 1,
          "note": "short form for the page: A license is required to export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) items specified in ECCNs … 3A090.a; … 4A090.a; … to or within any destination worldwide."
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "742.6-b10iiiA1-s1",
          "quotation": "There is a case-by-case license review policy for license applications for exports of commodities with a TPP (as defined in Technical Note 2 to 3A090.a and 3A090.b) less than 21,000, and a 'total DRAM bandwidth' (as defined in the notes to paragraph (dd)(1) in supplement no. 2 to part 748) less than 6,500 GB/s, when destined to end-users located in China or Macau, provided the applicant provides the additional information described in supplement no. 2 to part 748 under paragraph (dd).",
          "section": "15 CFR 742.6(b)(10)(iii)(A)(1), first sentence",
          "source": "15 CFR 742.6, Regional stability (eCFR)",
          "document_date": "2026-07-23",
          "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-742/section-742.6",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:47Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "742.6-b10iiiA1-s2",
          "quotation": "All other applications for exports, reexports, or transfers (in-country) will be reviewed under a presumption of denial to or within Macau or destinations specified in Country Group D:5 or to an entity headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, either Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5.",
          "section": "15 CFR 742.6(b)(10)(iii)(A)(1), second sentence",
          "source": "15 CFR 742.6, Regional stability (eCFR)",
          "document_date": "2026-07-23",
          "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-742/section-742.6",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:47Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "fr2026-summary",
          "quotation": "The Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) is revising its license review policy for exports of certain semiconductors to China and Macau—changing it from a presumption of denial to a case-by-case review.",
          "section": "91 FR 1684, Summary",
          "source": "91 FR 1684, FR Doc. 2026-00789 (final rule)",
          "document_date": "2026-01-15",
          "url": "https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/01/15/2026-00789/revision-to-license-review-policy-for-advanced-computing-commodities",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:57:56Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "The line is a TPP under 21,000 and a total DRAM bandwidth under 6,500 GB/s. The case-by-case review covers exports to end users in China or Macau whose applicants supply the information in supplement no. 2 to part 748, paragraph (dd); every other application is reviewed under a presumption of denial. The citations are right. Chips in the 3A090.b band need their licence for China under 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(B), which the citation could add.",
      "source": "15 CFR 742.6, Regional stability (eCFR)"
    },
    {
      "id": "moved-today",
      "sentence": "Needs a licence.",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN",
      "words_if_changed": null,
      "quotation": "(iii)(A) Worldwide license requirement. A license is required to export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) items specified in ECCNs 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a; 3A090.a; 3D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, or 3A090.a); 3E001 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, or 3A090.a); 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a; 4A004.z.1; 4A005.z.1; 4A090.a; 4D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, and 4A005.z.1); 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090.a); 4E001 (for commodities controlled by 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, 4A005.z.1, 4A090.a or “software” specified by 4D001 (for 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, or 4A005.z.1), or 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090.a)); 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a; 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a; 5A992.z.1; 5D002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a, z.6.a, z.7.a, z.8.a, and z.9.a; 5D992.z.1; 5E002 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a or 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a or “software” specified by 5D002 (for 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a or 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a commodities)); or 5E992 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A992.z.1 or “software” controlled by 5D992.z.1.) to or within any destination worldwide.",
      "section": "15 CFR 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A)",
      "document_date": "2026-07-23",
      "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-742/section-742.6",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:47Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "moved route, B (China end) and L (right column)",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "742.6-a6iiiA",
          "quotation": "(iii)(A) Worldwide license requirement. A license is required to export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) items specified in ECCNs 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a; 3A090.a; 3D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, or 3A090.a); 3E001 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, or 3A090.a); 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a; 4A004.z.1; 4A005.z.1; 4A090.a; 4D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, and 4A005.z.1); 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090.a); 4E001 (for commodities controlled by 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, 4A005.z.1, 4A090.a or “software” specified by 4D001 (for 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, or 4A005.z.1), or 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090.a)); 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a; 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a; 5A992.z.1; 5D002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a, z.6.a, z.7.a, z.8.a, and z.9.a; 5D992.z.1; 5E002 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a or 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a or “software” specified by 5D002 (for 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a or 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a commodities)); or 5E992 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A992.z.1 or “software” controlled by 5D992.z.1.) to or within any destination worldwide.",
          "section": "15 CFR 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A)",
          "source": "15 CFR 742.6, Regional stability (eCFR)",
          "document_date": "2026-07-23",
          "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-742/section-742.6",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:47Z",
          "authority_tier": 1,
          "note": "short form for the page: A license is required to export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) items specified in ECCNs … 3A090.a; … 4A090.a; … to or within any destination worldwide."
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "742.6-a6iiiB",
          "quotation": "(B) License Requirement for the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and Country Groups D:1, D:4, or D:5 (excluding destinations also specified in Country Groups A:5 or A:6). A license is required to export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) items specified in ECCNs 3A001.z.1.b, z.2.b, z.3.b, z.4.b; 3A090.b; 3D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z.1.b, z.2.b, z.3.b, z.4.b; 3A090.b); 3E001 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z.1.b, z.2.b, z.3.b, z.4.b, or 3A090.b); 4A003.z.1.b, z.2.b; 4A004.z.2; 4A005.z.2; 4A090.b; 4D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A003.z.1.b, z.2.b, 4A004.z.2, and 4A005.z.2); 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090.b); 4E001 (for commodities controlled by 4A003.z.1.b, z.2.b, 4A004.z.2, 4A005.z.2, 4A090.b or “software” specified by 4D001 (for 4A003.z.1.b, z.2.b, 4A004.z.2, or 4A005.z.2), or 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090.b)); 5A002.z.1.b, z.2.b, z.3.b, z.4.b, z.5.b; 5A004.z.1.b, z.2.b; 5A992.z.2; 5D002.z.1.b, z.2.b, z.3.b, z.4.b, z.5.b, z.6.b, z.7.b, z.8.b, and z.9.b; 5D992.z.2; 5E002 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A002.z.1.b, z.2.b, z.3.b, z.4.b, z.5.b or 5A004.z.1.b, z.2.b or “software” specified by 5D002 (for 5A002. z.1.b, z.2.b, z.3.b, z.4.b, z.5.b or 5A004.z.1.b, z.2.b commodities)); or 5E992 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A992.z.2 or “software” controlled by 5D992.z.2.) to or within the UAE or a destination in Country Groups D:1, D:4, or D:5 (excluding destinations also specified in Country Groups A:5 or A:6), except that a license is not required when the ultimate consignee and all end users are approved entities in the UAE listed in supplement no. 8 to part 740 and specified as approved to receive the items covered by this paragraph.",
          "section": "15 CFR 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(B)",
          "source": "15 CFR 742.6, Regional stability (eCFR)",
          "document_date": "2026-07-23",
          "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-742/section-742.6",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:47Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-transfer",
          "quotation": "Transfers (in-country), defined as a change in end use or end user, of advanced computing ICs and commodities subject to the EAR already in the possession of parties such as IaaS providers, if there is “knowledge” that the items will be used by the transferee to train AI models for or on behalf of parties headquartered in D:5 countries (including China) or Macau.",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025 (for \"D:5 countries (including China)\")",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "source": "15 CFR 742.6, Regional stability (eCFR)"
    },
    {
      "id": "bought-today",
      "sentence": "Needs a licence wherever the buyer is, since 17 Nov 2023.",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN",
      "words_if_changed": null,
      "quotation": "The Department of Commerce, Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) is issuing this guidance to clarify that a license is required to export advanced computing items to entities headquartered in Country Group D:5 (see supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the Export Administration Regulations (EAR) (15 CFR parts 730-774)) or Macau or with an ultimate parent company headquartered in Country Group D:5 or Macau – even if the entities themselves are located outside Country Group D:5 or Macau.",
      "section": "BIS guidance of 31 May 2026, para. 1",
      "document_date": "2026-05-31",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/bis-guidance-may-31-2026.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:38Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "bought route, B (square abroad) and L (right column)",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "guidance-s1",
          "quotation": "The Department of Commerce, Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) is issuing this guidance to clarify that a license is required to export advanced computing items to entities headquartered in Country Group D:5 (see supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the Export Administration Regulations (EAR) (15 CFR parts 730-774)) or Macau or with an ultimate parent company headquartered in Country Group D:5 or Macau – even if the entities themselves are located outside Country Group D:5 or Macau.",
          "section": "BIS guidance of 31 May 2026, para. 1",
          "source": "BIS, Guidance Regarding Enforcement of License Requirements for Advanced Computing Items for Entities Headquartered in Country Group D:5 and Macau [May 31, 2026]",
          "document_date": "2026-05-31",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/bis-guidance-may-31-2026.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:38Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "guidance-first",
          "quotation": "This license requirement was first introduced on November 17, 2023. It was implemented via an end-user control in § 744.23(a)(3) of the EAR and applied to all advanced computing items (e.g., those specified in Export Control Classification Numbers (ECCNs) 3A090.a and .b, 4A090.a and .b, and related .z paragraph items).",
          "section": "BIS guidance of 31 May 2026, para. 2",
          "source": "BIS, Guidance Regarding Enforcement of License Requirements for Advanced Computing Items for Entities Headquartered in Country Group D:5 and Macau [May 31, 2026]",
          "document_date": "2026-05-31",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/bis-guidance-may-31-2026.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:38Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "guidance-742",
          "quotation": "Specifically, a license requirement continues to apply under § 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A) of the EAR to all destinations outside the United States for these advanced computing items when such items are for entities headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, Country Group D:5 or Macau.",
          "section": "BIS guidance of 31 May 2026, para. 3",
          "source": "BIS, Guidance Regarding Enforcement of License Requirements for Advanced Computing Items for Entities Headquartered in Country Group D:5 and Macau [May 31, 2026]",
          "document_date": "2026-05-31",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/bis-guidance-may-31-2026.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:38Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "fr2023-eff",
          "quotation": "This rule is effective November 17, 2023, except for amendatory instruction 11 amending supplement no. 1 to part 736 of the EAR, which is effective from November 17, 2023, to January 1, 2026.",
          "section": "88 FR 73458, Dates",
          "source": "88 FR 73458, FR Doc. 2023-23055 (interim final rule)",
          "document_date": "2023-10-25",
          "url": "https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/10/25/2023-23055/implementation-of-additional-export-controls-certain-advanced-computing-items-supercomputer-and",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:57:54Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "fr2023-a3i",
          "quotation": "A license will be required under paragraph (a)(3)(i) for the export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) to or within any destination not specified in Country Groups D:1, D:4, or D:5 (excluding any destination also specified in Country Groups A:5 or A:6) of commodities identified in ECCNs 3A001.z, 3A090, 4A003.z, 4A004.z, 4A005.z, 4A090, 5A002.z, 5A004.z, 5A992.z, or 5D002.z, or 5D992.z when the exporter, reexporter, or transferor has “knowledge” at the time of the export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) that item is destined for any entity that is headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, either Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5.",
          "section": "88 FR 73458, preamble on § 744.23(a)(3)(i)",
          "source": "88 FR 73458, FR Doc. 2023-23055 (interim final rule)",
          "document_date": "2023-10-25",
          "url": "https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/10/25/2023-23055/implementation-of-additional-export-controls-certain-advanced-computing-items-supercomputer-and",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:57:54Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "744.23-a",
          "quotation": "you may not export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) without a license any item subject to the EAR described in paragraphs (a)(1) through (4) of this section when you have “knowledge” at the time of export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) that the item is destined for a destination, end use, or type of end user described in paragraphs (a)(1) through (4) of this section, unless excluded by paragraph (a)(5) of this section.",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.23(a)",
          "source": "15 CFR 744.23 (eCFR)",
          "document_date": "2026-01-15",
          "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-744/section-744.23",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "744.23-a3iA",
          "quotation": "(3) Advanced computing items. (i)(A) Any item subject to the EAR and specified in ECCN 3A001.z.1.b, z.2.b, z.3.b, z.4.b; 3A090.b; 4A003.z.1.b, z.2.b; 4A004.z.2; 4A005.z.2; 4A090.b; 5A002.z.1.b, z.2.b, z.3.b, z.4.b, z.5.b; 5A004.z.1.b, z.2.b; 5A992.z.2, 5D002.z.1.b, z.2.b, z.3.b, z.4.b, z.5.b, z.6.b, z.7.b, z.8.b, and z.9.b; 5D992.z.2 destined to any destination other than those specified in Country Groups D:1, D:4, or D:5 (excluding any destination also specified in Country Groups A:5 or A:6) for an entity that is headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, either Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5 (e.g., a PRC-headquartered cloud or data server provider located outside of Country Groups D:1, D:4, or D:5 (excluding any destination also specified in Country Groups A:5 or A:6)).",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.23(a)(3)(i)(A)",
          "source": "15 CFR 744.23 (eCFR)",
          "document_date": "2026-01-15",
          "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-744/section-744.23",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "guidance-exception",
          "quotation": "Exporters should continue to seek BIS licenses for such transactions, unless a license exception specified in § 740.2(a)(9)(ii) is available.",
          "section": "BIS guidance of 31 May 2026, para. 3, last sentence",
          "source": "BIS, Guidance Regarding Enforcement of License Requirements for Advanced Computing Items for Entities Headquartered in Country Group D:5 and Macau [May 31, 2026]",
          "document_date": "2026-05-31",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/bis-guidance-may-31-2026.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:38Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Under the route name \"Bought abroad\", \"wherever the buyer is\" reads as anywhere abroad, which is BIS's \"all destinations outside the United States\". The January 2025 rule moved the .a chips from 744.23 into 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A) (BIS, 31 May 2026); the .b band stays in 744.23(a)(3)(i)(A), where the licence turns on the exporter's knowledge. The citations are right; the 31 May 2026 guidance, which says this in BIS's words, could be added to them.",
      "source": "BIS, Guidance Regarding Enforcement of License Requirements for Advanced Computing Items for Entities Headquartered in Country Group D:5 and Macau [May 31, 2026]"
    },
    {
      "id": "rented-today",
      "sentence": "No licence requirement; a bill has passed the House.",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED WITH OTHER WORDS",
      "words_if_changed": "Only a catch-all; a bill has passed the House.",
      "quotation": "The following activities may trigger a license requirement under the catch-all controls of part 744 of the EAR when there is “knowledge” (see inset below for further information about “knowledge” under the EAR) that the AI model will be used for a WMD or military-intelligence end use/user:",
      "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1",
      "document_date": "2025-05-13",
      "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "rented route, B (square abroad) and L (right column)",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "ao2009",
          "quotation": "The service of providing computational capacity would not be subject to the EAR as the service provider is not shipping or transmitting any commodity, software, or technology to the user.",
          "section": "BIS Advisory Opinion, 13 Jan 2009, p. 2, answer (1)",
          "source": "BIS Advisory Opinion of 13 Jan 2009 on grid and cloud computing services (scanned letter)",
          "document_date": "2009-01-13",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/1343",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:35Z",
          "authority_tier": 1,
          "note": "read from the page image of p. 2 (rendered from the saved PDF); the PDF's character-recognition layer prints \"thc\", \"scrvicc\" and \"uscr\" for \"the\", \"service\" and \"user\""
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "734.13-a1",
          "quotation": "(a) Except as set forth in § 734.17 or § 734.18, Export means: (1) An actual shipment or transmission out of the United States, including the sending or taking of an item out of the United States, in any manner;",
          "section": "15 CFR 734.13(a)(1)",
          "source": "15 CFR 734.13, Export (eCFR)",
          "document_date": "2017-01-03",
          "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-734/section-734.13",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:54Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-lead",
          "quotation": "The following activities may trigger a license requirement under the catch-all controls of part 744 of the EAR when there is “knowledge” (see inset below for further information about “knowledge” under the EAR) that the AI model will be used for a WMD or military-intelligence end use/user:",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-transfer",
          "quotation": "Transfers (in-country), defined as a change in end use or end user, of advanced computing ICs and commodities subject to the EAR already in the possession of parties such as IaaS providers, if there is “knowledge” that the items will be used by the transferee to train AI models for or on behalf of parties headquartered in D:5 countries (including China) or Macau.",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1, second bullet",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "billstatus-pass",
          "quotation": "On motion to suspend the rules and pass the bill, as amended Agreed to by the Yeas and Nays: (2/3 required): 369 - 22 (Roll no. 13).",
          "section": "H.R. 2683 bill status, action of 12 Jan 2026",
          "source": "BILLSTATUS-119hr2683.xml (Library of Congress bill status, on govinfo)",
          "document_date": "2026-01-15",
          "url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/bulkdata/BILLSTATUS/119/hr/BILLSTATUS-119hr2683.xml",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:00:42Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "hr2683-passed",
          "quotation": "Passed the House of Representatives January 12, 2026.",
          "section": "H.R. 2683, engrossed text, attestation",
          "source": "H.R. 2683 (119th Congress), Engrossed in House (GPO)",
          "document_date": "2026-01-12",
          "url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr2683eh/html/BILLS-119hr2683eh.htm",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:10Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "billstatus-latest",
          "quotation": "Received in the Senate and Read twice and referred to the Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs.",
          "section": "H.R. 2683 bill status, latest action (13 Jan 2026)",
          "source": "BILLSTATUS-119hr2683.xml (Library of Congress bill status, on govinfo)",
          "document_date": "2026-01-15",
          "url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/bulkdata/BILLSTATUS/119/hr/BILLSTATUS-119hr2683.xml",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:00:42Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "The sentence cites the 13 May 2025 statement, which says renting can trigger a licence requirement under the catch-all controls when there is knowledge of a WMD or military-intelligence use; \"No licence requirement\" contradicts its own citation. \"Catch-all\" is the statement's word; the lede gives the condition. The bill half is right: the House passed H.R. 2683 on 12 Jan 2026, 369 to 22 (Clerk, roll call 13); its latest action is referral to Senate Banking on 13 Jan 2026; no law is listed. S. 3519 has had no action since its referral on 17 Dec 2025. 734.13(a)(1) defines an export; the proposition that renting is not one is BIS's 2009 advisory opinion, which the citation could add. congress.gov refused both clients (a Cloudflare challenge page), so the actions were read from the bill-status file and the Clerk's roll call.",
      "printed_form": "Needs a licence only if the provider knows of a weapons-of-mass-destruction or military-intelligence use; a bill has passed the House.",
      "printed_form_verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN",
      "printed_form_passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-lead",
          "quotation": "The following activities may trigger a license requirement under the catch-all controls of part 744 of the EAR when there is “knowledge” (see inset below for further information about “knowledge” under the EAR) that the AI model will be used for a WMD or military-intelligence end use/user:",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-transfer",
          "quotation": "Transfers (in-country), defined as a change in end use or end user, of advanced computing ICs and commodities subject to the EAR already in the possession of parties such as IaaS providers, if there is “knowledge” that the items will be used by the transferee to train AI models for or on behalf of parties headquartered in D:5 countries (including China) or Macau.",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1, second bullet",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "billstatus-pass",
          "quotation": "On motion to suspend the rules and pass the bill, as amended Agreed to by the Yeas and Nays: (2/3 required): 369 - 22 (Roll no. 13).",
          "section": "H.R. 2683 bill status, action of 12 Jan 2026",
          "source": "BILLSTATUS-119hr2683.xml (Library of Congress bill status, on govinfo)",
          "document_date": "2026-01-15",
          "url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/bulkdata/BILLSTATUS/119/hr/BILLSTATUS-119hr2683.xml",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:00:42Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "billstatus-latest",
          "quotation": "Received in the Senate and Read twice and referred to the Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs.",
          "section": "H.R. 2683 bill status, latest action (13 Jan 2026)",
          "source": "BILLSTATUS-119hr2683.xml (Library of Congress bill status, on govinfo)",
          "document_date": "2026-01-15",
          "url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/bulkdata/BILLSTATUS/119/hr/BILLSTATUS-119hr2683.xml",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:00:42Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "printed_form_note": "\"Only if\" states knowledge as a necessary condition and claims no more, which matches \"may trigger … when there is “knowledge”\". That nothing else makes renting need a licence rests on the 2009 advisory opinion (providing computational capacity is not subject to the EAR) and on no BIS rule on remote access since (searches as in lede-2): tier 4 for the \"only\". The use known of is the model's, which the route's context carries. The bill half is unchanged and supported.",
      "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)"
    },
    {
      "id": "rented-case",
      "sentence": "A lawful rental does not produce a case.",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN",
      "words_if_changed": null,
      "quotation": "Parties that do not obtain prior BIS authorization to engage in these transactions or activities may be subject to potential civil or criminal enforcement action if a violation of the EAR occurs.",
      "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1",
      "document_date": "2025-05-13",
      "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
      "authority_tier": 4,
      "where": "rented route, the case grade's sentence (B and L)",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-enforcement",
          "quotation": "Parties that do not obtain prior BIS authorization to engage in these transactions or activities may be subject to potential civil or criminal enforcement action if a violation of the EAR occurs.",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-entitylist",
          "quotation": "foreign parties acting contrary to U.S. national security and foreign policy interests, including by training AI models that could support WMD or military-intelligence end uses for or on behalf of parties headquartered in Country Group D:5 (including China) or Macau, may be added to the Entity List, even where no violation of the EAR occurs.",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 2",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Enforcement follows \"if a violation of the EAR occurs\", so a lawful rental produces no case (my inference from the statement, tier 4). The same statement says a foreign party may be added to the Entity List \"even where no violation of the EAR occurs\": a listing is an official body's document on this page, not a case, so the sentence stands, but no line on the page may say a lawful rental has no consequence.",
      "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)"
    },
    {
      "id": "tick-2022-10",
      "sentence": "needs a licence",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN",
      "words_if_changed": null,
      "quotation": "A license is required for items specified in ECCNs 3A090, 3B090, 4A090, 5A992 (that meet or exceed the performance parameters of ECCNs 3A090 or 4A090) and associated software and technology in 3D001 (for 3A090 or 3B090), 3E001 (for 3A090 or 3B090), 3B090, or 3D001 (for 3A090 or 3B090), 4D090, 4E001 (for 4A090 and 4D090), and 5D992 (that meet or exceed the performance parameters of ECCNs 3A090 or 4A090) being exported, reexported, or transferred (in-country) to or within the China.",
      "section": "87 FR 62186, amendatory instruction 11, § 742.6(a)(6)(i)",
      "document_date": "2022-10-13",
      "url": "https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/10/13/2022-21658/implementation-of-additional-export-controls-certain-advanced-computing-and-semiconductor",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:58:12Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "L, sold and moved lanes, tick at Oct 2022",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "fr2022-a6i",
          "quotation": "A license is required for items specified in ECCNs 3A090, 3B090, 4A090, 5A992 (that meet or exceed the performance parameters of ECCNs 3A090 or 4A090) and associated software and technology in 3D001 (for 3A090 or 3B090), 3E001 (for 3A090 or 3B090), 3B090, or 3D001 (for 3A090 or 3B090), 4D090, 4E001 (for 4A090 and 4D090), and 5D992 (that meet or exceed the performance parameters of ECCNs 3A090 or 4A090) being exported, reexported, or transferred (in-country) to or within the China.",
          "section": "87 FR 62186, amendatory instruction 11, § 742.6(a)(6)(i)",
          "source": "87 FR 62186, FR Doc. 2022-21658 (interim final rule)",
          "document_date": "2022-10-13",
          "url": "https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/10/13/2022-21658/implementation-of-additional-export-controls-certain-advanced-computing-and-semiconductor",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:58:12Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "fr2022-eff",
          "quotation": "Effective on October 7, 2022, are the following instructions: 7 (§ 740.2), 9 (§ 740.10), 11 (§ 742.6), 17 (§ 744.23), and 25 (supplement no. 1 to part 774).",
          "section": "87 FR 62186, Dates",
          "source": "87 FR 62186, FR Doc. 2022-21658 (interim final rule)",
          "document_date": "2022-10-13",
          "url": "https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/10/13/2022-21658/implementation-of-additional-export-controls-certain-advanced-computing-and-semiconductor",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:58:12Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "In 2022 the requirement sat in 742.6(a)(6)(i) and named China; it took effect on 7 Oct 2022, six days before publication.",
      "source": "87 FR 62186, FR Doc. 2022-21658 (interim final rule)"
    },
    {
      "id": "tick-2025-04",
      "sentence": "H20 needs a licence",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN",
      "words_if_changed": null,
      "quotation": "On April 9, 2025, the U.S. government, or USG, informed NVIDIA Corporation, or the Company, that the USG requires a license for export to China (including Hong Kong and Macau) and D:5 countries, or to companies headquartered or with an ultimate parent therein, of the Company’s H20 integrated circuits and any other circuits achieving the H20’s memory bandwidth, interconnect bandwidth, or combination thereof.",
      "section": "NVIDIA Form 8-K, Item 8.01",
      "document_date": "2025-04-15",
      "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1045810/000104581025000082/nvda-20250409.htm",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:03:15Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "L, sold lane, tick at Apr 2025",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "nvda-8k",
          "quotation": "On April 9, 2025, the U.S. government, or USG, informed NVIDIA Corporation, or the Company, that the USG requires a license for export to China (including Hong Kong and Macau) and D:5 countries, or to companies headquartered or with an ultimate parent therein, of the Company’s H20 integrated circuits and any other circuits achieving the H20’s memory bandwidth, interconnect bandwidth, or combination thereof.",
          "section": "NVIDIA Form 8-K, Item 8.01",
          "source": "NVIDIA Corporation, Form 8-K (Item 8.01), filed 15 Apr 2025, accession 0001045810-25-000082",
          "document_date": "2025-04-15",
          "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1045810/000104581025000082/nvda-20250409.htm",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:03:15Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "nvda-8k-indef",
          "quotation": "On April 14, 2025, the USG informed the Company that the license requirement will be in effect for the indefinite future.",
          "section": "NVIDIA Form 8-K, Item 8.01",
          "source": "NVIDIA Corporation, Form 8-K (Item 8.01), filed 15 Apr 2025, accession 0001045810-25-000082",
          "document_date": "2025-04-15",
          "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1045810/000104581025000082/nvda-20250409.htm",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:03:15Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "The notice itself is not public; the public source is NVIDIA's own filing (tier 1 as a company's statement), and the tick's citation should say so: \"NVIDIA Form 8-K, 15 Apr 2025\". The notice reached licences for China (including Hong Kong and Macau), D:5 countries and companies headquartered or with an ultimate parent there. I did not search the Federal Register for a publication of it. sec.gov refused curl with default headers (HTTP 403); nscurl with its own default headers returned the filing.",
      "citation_for_page": "NVIDIA Form 8-K, 15 Apr 2025",
      "source": "NVIDIA Corporation, Form 8-K (Item 8.01), filed 15 Apr 2025, accession 0001045810-25-000082"
    },
    {
      "id": "tick-2026-01",
      "sentence": "licensed case by case",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED WITH OTHER WORDS",
      "words_if_changed": "reviewed case by case",
      "quotation": "The Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) is revising its license review policy for exports of certain semiconductors to China and Macau—changing it from a presumption of denial to a case-by-case review.",
      "section": "91 FR 1684, Summary",
      "document_date": "2026-01-15",
      "url": "https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/01/15/2026-00789/revision-to-license-review-policy-for-advanced-computing-commodities",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:57:56Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "L, sold lane, tick at Jan 2026",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "fr2026-summary",
          "quotation": "The Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) is revising its license review policy for exports of certain semiconductors to China and Macau—changing it from a presumption of denial to a case-by-case review.",
          "section": "91 FR 1684, Summary",
          "source": "91 FR 1684, FR Doc. 2026-00789 (final rule)",
          "document_date": "2026-01-15",
          "url": "https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/01/15/2026-00789/revision-to-license-review-policy-for-advanced-computing-commodities",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:57:56Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "The rule changed how applications are reviewed, from a presumption of denial to case by case; \"licensed\" reads as if licences were granted by the rule.",
      "source": "91 FR 1684, FR Doc. 2026-00789 (final rule)"
    },
    {
      "id": "tick-2023-11",
      "sentence": "needs a licence",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN",
      "words_if_changed": null,
      "quotation": "This rule is effective November 17, 2023, except for amendatory instruction 11 amending supplement no. 1 to part 736 of the EAR, which is effective from November 17, 2023, to January 1, 2026.",
      "section": "88 FR 73458, Dates",
      "document_date": "2023-10-25",
      "url": "https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/10/25/2023-23055/implementation-of-additional-export-controls-certain-advanced-computing-items-supercomputer-and",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:57:54Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "L, bought lane, tick at Nov 2023",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "fr2023-eff",
          "quotation": "This rule is effective November 17, 2023, except for amendatory instruction 11 amending supplement no. 1 to part 736 of the EAR, which is effective from November 17, 2023, to January 1, 2026.",
          "section": "88 FR 73458, Dates",
          "source": "88 FR 73458, FR Doc. 2023-23055 (interim final rule)",
          "document_date": "2023-10-25",
          "url": "https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/10/25/2023-23055/implementation-of-additional-export-controls-certain-advanced-computing-items-supercomputer-and",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:57:54Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "guidance-first",
          "quotation": "This license requirement was first introduced on November 17, 2023. It was implemented via an end-user control in § 744.23(a)(3) of the EAR and applied to all advanced computing items (e.g., those specified in Export Control Classification Numbers (ECCNs) 3A090.a and .b, 4A090.a and .b, and related .z paragraph items).",
          "section": "BIS guidance of 31 May 2026, para. 2",
          "source": "BIS, Guidance Regarding Enforcement of License Requirements for Advanced Computing Items for Entities Headquartered in Country Group D:5 and Macau [May 31, 2026]",
          "document_date": "2026-05-31",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/bis-guidance-may-31-2026.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:38Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": null,
      "source": "88 FR 73458, FR Doc. 2023-23055 (interim final rule)"
    },
    {
      "id": "tick-2025-05",
      "sentence": "licence if the supplier knows",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED WITH OTHER WORDS",
      "words_if_changed": "catch-all licence if supplier knows",
      "quotation": "The following activities may trigger a license requirement under the catch-all controls of part 744 of the EAR when there is “knowledge” (see inset below for further information about “knowledge” under the EAR) that the AI model will be used for a WMD or military-intelligence end use/user:",
      "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1",
      "document_date": "2025-05-13",
      "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "L, rented lane, tick at May 2025",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-update",
          "quotation": "As an update to previous advisory opinions issued by the Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS), the following types of activities may be subject to an export authorization under the Export Administration Regulations (EAR), 15 C.F.R. parts 730 - 774.",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1, first sentence",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-lead",
          "quotation": "The following activities may trigger a license requirement under the catch-all controls of part 744 of the EAR when there is “knowledge” (see inset below for further information about “knowledge” under the EAR) that the AI model will be used for a WMD or military-intelligence end use/user:",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-transfer",
          "quotation": "Transfers (in-country), defined as a change in end use or end user, of advanced computing ICs and commodities subject to the EAR already in the possession of parties such as IaaS providers, if there is “knowledge” that the items will be used by the transferee to train AI models for or on behalf of parties headquartered in D:5 countries (including China) or Macau.",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1, second bullet",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "The statement never says \"supplier\"; it names \"the exporter, reexporter, or transferor\" and a \"U.S. person\", for which \"supplier\" is fair plain English. What the supplier must know is narrow: that the model will be used for a WMD or military-intelligence end use or user. Five words cannot carry that; naming the catch-all ties the tick to the controls the statement invokes, and the lede states the condition. The statement is BIS guidance, not a rule (\"As an update to previous advisory opinions\"): drawn as a change in BIS's stated position, it is a change.",
      "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)"
    },
    {
      "id": "tick-2026-01-house",
      "sentence": "a bill has passed the House",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN",
      "words_if_changed": null,
      "quotation": "On motion to suspend the rules and pass the bill, as amended Agreed to by the Yeas and Nays: (2/3 required): 369 - 22 (Roll no. 13).",
      "section": "H.R. 2683 bill status, action of 12 Jan 2026",
      "document_date": "2026-01-15",
      "url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/bulkdata/BILLSTATUS/119/hr/BILLSTATUS-119hr2683.xml",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:00:42Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "L, rented lane, tick at Jan 2026",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "billstatus-pass",
          "quotation": "On motion to suspend the rules and pass the bill, as amended Agreed to by the Yeas and Nays: (2/3 required): 369 - 22 (Roll no. 13).",
          "section": "H.R. 2683 bill status, action of 12 Jan 2026",
          "source": "BILLSTATUS-119hr2683.xml (Library of Congress bill status, on govinfo)",
          "document_date": "2026-01-15",
          "url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/bulkdata/BILLSTATUS/119/hr/BILLSTATUS-119hr2683.xml",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:00:42Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "hr2683-passed",
          "quotation": "Passed the House of Representatives January 12, 2026.",
          "section": "H.R. 2683, engrossed text, attestation",
          "source": "H.R. 2683 (119th Congress), Engrossed in House (GPO)",
          "document_date": "2026-01-12",
          "url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr2683eh/html/BILLS-119hr2683eh.htm",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:10Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "billstatus-latest",
          "quotation": "Received in the Senate and Read twice and referred to the Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs.",
          "section": "H.R. 2683 bill status, latest action (13 Jan 2026)",
          "source": "BILLSTATUS-119hr2683.xml (Library of Congress bill status, on govinfo)",
          "document_date": "2026-01-15",
          "url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/bulkdata/BILLSTATUS/119/hr/BILLSTATUS-119hr2683.xml",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:00:42Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Clerk of the House, roll call 13 of 12 Jan 2026: \"Remote Access Security Act\", result \"Passed\", yeas 369, nays 22, not voting 39.",
      "source": "BILLSTATUS-119hr2683.xml (Library of Congress bill status, on govinfo)"
    },
    {
      "id": "gate-licence",
      "sentence": "licence",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN",
      "words_if_changed": null,
      "quotation": "(iii)(A) Worldwide license requirement. A license is required to export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) items specified in ECCNs 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a; 3A090.a; 3D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, or 3A090.a); 3E001 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, or 3A090.a); 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a; 4A004.z.1; 4A005.z.1; 4A090.a; 4D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, and 4A005.z.1); 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090.a); 4E001 (for commodities controlled by 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, 4A005.z.1, 4A090.a or “software” specified by 4D001 (for 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, or 4A005.z.1), or 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090.a)); 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a; 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a; 5A992.z.1; 5D002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a, z.6.a, z.7.a, z.8.a, and z.9.a; 5D992.z.1; 5E002 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a or 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a or “software” specified by 5D002 (for 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a or 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a commodities)); or 5E992 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A992.z.1 or “software” controlled by 5D992.z.1.) to or within any destination worldwide.",
      "section": "15 CFR 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A)",
      "document_date": "2026-07-23",
      "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-742/section-742.6",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:47Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "B, gate on the border on the sold path",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "742.6-a6iiiA",
          "quotation": "(iii)(A) Worldwide license requirement. A license is required to export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) items specified in ECCNs 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a; 3A090.a; 3D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, or 3A090.a); 3E001 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, or 3A090.a); 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a; 4A004.z.1; 4A005.z.1; 4A090.a; 4D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, and 4A005.z.1); 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090.a); 4E001 (for commodities controlled by 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, 4A005.z.1, 4A090.a or “software” specified by 4D001 (for 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, or 4A005.z.1), or 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090.a)); 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a; 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a; 5A992.z.1; 5D002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a, z.6.a, z.7.a, z.8.a, and z.9.a; 5D992.z.1; 5E002 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a or 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a or “software” specified by 5D002 (for 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a or 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a commodities)); or 5E992 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A992.z.1 or “software” controlled by 5D992.z.1.) to or within any destination worldwide.",
          "section": "15 CFR 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A)",
          "source": "15 CFR 742.6, Regional stability (eCFR)",
          "document_date": "2026-07-23",
          "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-742/section-742.6",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:47Z",
          "authority_tier": 1,
          "note": "short form for the page: A license is required to export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) items specified in ECCNs … 3A090.a; … 4A090.a; … to or within any destination worldwide."
        }
      ],
      "note": null,
      "source": "15 CFR 742.6, Regional stability (eCFR)"
    },
    {
      "id": "handback-asymmetry",
      "sentence": "buying abroad needs a licence, renting does not",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED WITH OTHER WORDS",
      "words_if_changed": "buying abroad needs a licence; renting, a catch-all",
      "quotation": "The following activities may trigger a license requirement under the catch-all controls of part 744 of the EAR when there is “knowledge” (see inset below for further information about “knowledge” under the EAR) that the AI model will be used for a WMD or military-intelligence end use/user:",
      "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1",
      "document_date": "2025-05-13",
      "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "HANDBACK.md only (\"Which I would keep\"); not printed on the page",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-lead",
          "quotation": "The following activities may trigger a license requirement under the catch-all controls of part 744 of the EAR when there is “knowledge” (see inset below for further information about “knowledge” under the EAR) that the AI model will be used for a WMD or military-intelligence end use/user:",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "The same correction as rented-today. Not printed, so it binds nothing on the page.",
      "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)"
    },
    {
      "id": "lede-2-renting",
      "sentence": "Renting that company time on the same chip in a data centre abroad needs one where the provider knows the AI model will be used for weapons of mass destruction or military intelligence; BIS says it also needs one where such a company uses more than half the data centre’s compute.",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED WITH OTHER WORDS",
      "words_if_changed": "Renting that company time on the same chip in a data centre abroad needs one where the provider knows the AI model will be used for weapons of mass destruction or military intelligence; BIS says the chip also needs one where such a company is known to use more than half the data centre’s compute.",
      "quotation": "This end-use control thus is not, and has never been limited only to exports, reexports, and transfers (in-country) destined to such entities of concern as ultimate consignees or end users, but extends to exports, reexports, or transfers (in-country) on behalf of these entities of concern, e.g., if an entity of concern was the purchaser in the transaction (directly or indirectly) or was the exclusive or primary (greater than 50 percent of total compute) remote end user of the data center computing capacity.",
      "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, preamble, section III.B (released text, p. 13, lines 606-618)",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "Opening, under the finding (the opening's `also`), first sentence",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "preamble-744.23-on-behalf",
          "quotation": "This end-use control thus is not, and has never been limited only to exports, reexports, and transfers (in-country) destined to such entities of concern as ultimate consignees or end users, but extends to exports, reexports, or transfers (in-country) on behalf of these entities of concern, e.g., if an entity of concern was the purchaser in the transaction (directly or indirectly) or was the exclusive or primary (greater than 50 percent of total compute) remote end user of the data center computing capacity.",
          "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, preamble, section III.B (released text, p. 13, lines 606-618)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "preamble-knowledge-next",
          "quotation": "Exporters, reexporters, and transferors are encouraged to examine both end-use controls in § 744.23(a)(3) and in new § 744.24 to the extent their transactions involve exports, reexports, or transfers to data centers outside of the United States where there is knowledge that a company headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent is headquartered in, Macau or D:5 will be an intended remote end user.",
          "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, preamble, section III.B (released text, pp. 13-14, lines 618-629)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "preamble-2023-intent",
          "quotation": "As stated in BIS’s October 2023 Advanced Computing/Supercomputing (“AC/S”) IFR (88 FR 73458) this control was intended to ensure that the national security and foreign policy objectives of the October 7, 2022 IFR and the AC/S IFR are not undermined by Macau, the People’s Republic of China (PRC), or other Country Group D:5 headquartered entities setting up cloud servers or data centers in other countries to allow these entities of concern to continue to train their SI models in ways that would be contrary to U.S. national security and foreign policy interests.",
          "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, preamble, section III.B (released text, p. 13, lines 594-606)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "744.23-a3iA",
          "quotation": "Any item subject to the EAR and specified in ECCN 3A001.z; 3A090 (except for 3A090.c); 4A003.z; 4A004.z; 4A005.z; 4A090; 5A002.z; 5A004.z; 5A992.z, 5D002.z; 5D992.z destined to any destination other than those specified in Country Groups D:1, D:4, or D:5 (excluding any destination also specified in Country Groups A:5 or A:6) for an entity that is headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, either Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5 (e.g., a PRC-headquartered cloud or data server provider located outside of Country Groups D:1, D:4, or D:5 (excluding any destination also specified in Country Groups A:5 or A:6)).",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.23(a)(3)(i)(A) (released text, p. 32, lines 1506-1520)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "ecfr-744.23-a-lead",
          "quotation": "In addition to the license requirements for items specified on the CCL, you may not export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) without a license any item subject to the EAR described in paragraphs (a)(1) through (4) of this section when you have “knowledge” at the time of export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) that the item is destined for a destination, end use, or type of end user described in paragraphs (a)(1) through (4) of this section, unless excluded by paragraph (a)(5) of this section.",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.23(a)",
          "source": "15 CFR 744.23 (eCFR)",
          "document_date": "2026-01-15",
          "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-744/section-744.23",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-lead",
          "quotation": "The following activities may trigger a license requirement under the catch-all controls of part 744 of the EAR when there is “knowledge” (see inset below for further information about “knowledge” under the EAR) that the AI model will be used for a WMD or military-intelligence end use/user:",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-transfer",
          "quotation": "Transfers (in-country), defined as a change in end use or end user, of advanced computing ICs and commodities subject to the EAR already in the possession of parties such as IaaS providers, if there is “knowledge” that the items will be used by the transferee to train AI models for or on behalf of parties headquartered in D:5 countries (including China) or Macau.",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1, second bullet",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "The preamble's statement (p. 13) concerns the export, reexport or in-country transfer of the chips made 'on behalf of' an entity of concern, e.g. where it 'was the exclusive or primary (greater than 50 percent of total compute) remote end user'; the control it interprets applies only 'when you have “knowledge”' (eCFR § 744.23(a)), as BIS's next sentence repeats ('where there is knowledge'). 'It also needs one' made the rental the licensed act and dropped the knowledge test; 'the chip also needs one' puts the licence on the chip's export, reexport or transfer, which takes in the rental where it changes the chip's end user (BIS, May 2025: a transfer (in-country) is 'a change in end use or end user'). In force today § 744.23(a)(3)(i)(A) names only the .b items; the rule extends it to all of 3A090 except 3A090.c (high-bandwidth memory) from publication, and BIS says its reading 'has never been limited', so the words hold on both sides as a report of what BIS says. 'BIS says' is fair: the AGENCY line reads 'The Department of Commerce', but the preamble speaks as the bureau that received the inquiries and wrote the 2023 rule. The first clause rests on the first reader's cuts of the 2025 statement, not reopened.",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026"
    },
    {
      "id": "lede-3-unpublished",
      "sentence": "A rule Commerce released on 16 Nov 2026 requires a licence, once it is published in the Federal Register, for chips the exporter knows are bound for a data centre that gives or will give such companies access to more than 12,000,000 aggregate TPP, the sum of each chip’s total processing performance.",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN",
      "words_if_changed": null,
      "quotation": "without a license if you have “knowledge” at the time of the export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) that the item is destined to a data center to or within any destination worldwide that is providing or will provide access to more than 12,000,000 “aggregate TPP” either at one data center or through ‘linked data centers’ to or for companies headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5 in supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the EAR.",
      "section": "15 CFR 744.24(a)(1) (released text, p. 33, lines 1580-1592)",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "Opening, under the finding, second sentence",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "744.24-a1-core",
          "quotation": "without a license if you have “knowledge” at the time of the export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) that the item is destined to a data center to or within any destination worldwide that is providing or will provide access to more than 12,000,000 “aggregate TPP” either at one data center or through ‘linked data centers’ to or for companies headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5 in supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the EAR.",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.24(a)(1) (released text, p. 33, lines 1580-1592)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "dates",
          "quotation": "This rule is effective [INSERT DATE OF PUBLICATION IN THE FEDERAL REGISTER].",
          "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, DATES (released text, p. 3, lines 96-98)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "772.1-aggregate-tpp",
          "quotation": "When referring to a group of integrated circuits (ICs) or commodities (e.g., in a license application or other authorization), the “aggregate TPP” of the ICs or commodities is the sum of the total processing performance (TPP), as defined in the Technical Notes to ECCN 3A090, of all of the ICs or commodities specified in ECCNs 3A001.z; 3A090 (except for 3A090.c); 4A003.z; 4A004.z; 4A005.z; 4A090; 5A002.z; 5A004.z; 5A992.z in the group.",
          "section": "15 CFR 772.1, Aggregate TPP (released text, p. 44, lines 2090-2098)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "preamble-knowingly",
          "quotation": "You may not knowingly export, reexport, or transfer (in-county) items specified in paragraph (a) of § 744.24 for use in a data center to or within any destination worldwide that will provide access to more than 12,000,000 “aggregate TPP” (either at one data center or through ‘linked data centers’ (including digitally-linked infrastructure, not just physically-linked infrastructure) to companies headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5 in supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the EAR.",
          "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, preamble, section III.A (released text, p. 8, lines 358-370)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "744.24-note3-redflag",
          "quotation": "A foreign data center declining or being unable to provide information sufficient to verify compliance with this end use control shall be considered a red flag that presumptively provides you with “knowledge” unless you are able to resolve that red flag before proceeding with the transaction.",
          "section": "Note 3 to 15 CFR 744.24(a)(1) (released text, p. 34, lines 1631-1637)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "summary-first",
          "quotation": "First, this rule establishes new restrictions which will apply for exports, reexports, or transfers (in-country) to overseas data centers that remotely supply significant volumes of compute to companies headquartered in Country Group D:5 or Macau. These restrictions will undermine the ability of companies headquartered in countries of concern from using U.S. advanced Super Intelligence (SI) semiconductors to train advanced SI models. Data centers, foreign foundries, and chip exporters are required to perform robust due diligence on their customers, including any direct or indirect ownership or control by persons in Country Group D:5 or Macau, as part of complying with this new control. The license requirement will not apply to commercial recommender systems, such as those used by online retailers or social media companies, as these functions do not pose the same national security threat.",
          "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, SUMMARY (released text, p. 1, lines 23-41)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "preamble-2023-intent",
          "quotation": "As stated in BIS’s October 2023 Advanced Computing/Supercomputing (“AC/S”) IFR (88 FR 73458) this control was intended to ensure that the national security and foreign policy objectives of the October 7, 2022 IFR and the AC/S IFR are not undermined by Macau, the People’s Republic of China (PRC), or other Country Group D:5 headquartered entities setting up cloud servers or data centers in other countries to allow these entities of concern to continue to train their SI models in ways that would be contrary to U.S. national security and foreign policy interests.",
          "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, preamble, section III.B (released text, p. 13, lines 594-606)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Every part is in § 744.24(a)(1), § 772.1 or the DATES line. The sentence states sufficient conditions and no 'only': 'the exporter' is one of the rule's exporter, reexporter or transferor; 'gives ... access' is the 'to' half of 'to or for'; one data centre is one case of 'one data center or ... linked data centers'; companies headquartered in China are a subset of Macau or D:5 (the preamble counts the PRC among D:5). 'Knows' renders 'knowledge' as the preamble itself does ('You may not knowingly export', p. 8); Note 3 makes a data centre's refusal of KYC information a red flag that presumptively gives knowledge, which the sentence does not deny. The commercial recommender exclusion is on the rented card, not here. 'Chips': (a)(1) leaves out 3A090.c, which is high-bandwidth memory (eCFR supplement no. 1 to part 774). The release date is not in the rule's text; it rests on the lane's record of the bis.gov posting (FACTS.md, read 16 Nov 2026 16:18Z), not opened by this reader.",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026"
    },
    {
      "id": "lede-3-in-force",
      "sentence": "Since {published} a Commerce rule has also required one for chips the exporter knows are bound for a data centre that gives or will give such companies access to more than 12,000,000 aggregate TPP, the sum of each chip’s total processing performance.",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN",
      "words_if_changed": null,
      "quotation": "without a license if you have “knowledge” at the time of the export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) that the item is destined to a data center to or within any destination worldwide that is providing or will provide access to more than 12,000,000 “aggregate TPP” either at one data center or through ‘linked data centers’ to or for companies headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5 in supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the EAR.",
      "section": "15 CFR 744.24(a)(1) (released text, p. 33, lines 1580-1592)",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "Opening, under the finding, second sentence",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "744.24-a1-core",
          "quotation": "without a license if you have “knowledge” at the time of the export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) that the item is destined to a data center to or within any destination worldwide that is providing or will provide access to more than 12,000,000 “aggregate TPP” either at one data center or through ‘linked data centers’ to or for companies headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5 in supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the EAR.",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.24(a)(1) (released text, p. 33, lines 1580-1592)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "dates",
          "quotation": "This rule is effective [INSERT DATE OF PUBLICATION IN THE FEDERAL REGISTER].",
          "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, DATES (released text, p. 3, lines 96-98)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "772.1-aggregate-tpp",
          "quotation": "When referring to a group of integrated circuits (ICs) or commodities (e.g., in a license application or other authorization), the “aggregate TPP” of the ICs or commodities is the sum of the total processing performance (TPP), as defined in the Technical Notes to ECCN 3A090, of all of the ICs or commodities specified in ECCNs 3A001.z; 3A090 (except for 3A090.c); 4A003.z; 4A004.z; 4A005.z; 4A090; 5A002.z; 5A004.z; 5A992.z in the group.",
          "section": "15 CFR 772.1, Aggregate TPP (released text, p. 44, lines 2090-2098)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "Read as 'Since 20 Nov 2026 a Commerce rule has also required one ...' against the released text: the rule is effective on publication (DATES), so the requirement runs from the Federal Register date; the rest as lede-3-unpublished. 'One' takes its antecedent from lede-2-renting's 'needs one', which the reader's words keep. Re-read DATES and (a)(1) in the published text at publication.",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026"
    },
    {
      "id": "rented-catch-all",
      "sentence": "Needs a licence where the provider knows of a weapons-of-mass-destruction or military-intelligence use; BIS says it also needs one where a company headquartered in China uses more than half the data centre’s compute. A bill has passed the House.",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED WITH OTHER WORDS",
      "words_if_changed": "Needs a licence where the provider knows of a weapons-of-mass-destruction or military-intelligence use; BIS says the chips also need one where a company headquartered in China is known to use more than half the data centre’s compute. A bill has passed the House.",
      "quotation": "This end-use control thus is not, and has never been limited only to exports, reexports, and transfers (in-country) destined to such entities of concern as ultimate consignees or end users, but extends to exports, reexports, or transfers (in-country) on behalf of these entities of concern, e.g., if an entity of concern was the purchaser in the transaction (directly or indirectly) or was the exclusive or primary (greater than 50 percent of total compute) remote end user of the data center computing capacity.",
      "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, preamble, section III.B (released text, p. 13, lines 606-618)",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "First screen, rented route's card: under the label \"Today\" before publication; second line, no label, after",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "preamble-744.23-on-behalf",
          "quotation": "This end-use control thus is not, and has never been limited only to exports, reexports, and transfers (in-country) destined to such entities of concern as ultimate consignees or end users, but extends to exports, reexports, or transfers (in-country) on behalf of these entities of concern, e.g., if an entity of concern was the purchaser in the transaction (directly or indirectly) or was the exclusive or primary (greater than 50 percent of total compute) remote end user of the data center computing capacity.",
          "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, preamble, section III.B (released text, p. 13, lines 606-618)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "preamble-knowledge-next",
          "quotation": "Exporters, reexporters, and transferors are encouraged to examine both end-use controls in § 744.23(a)(3) and in new § 744.24 to the extent their transactions involve exports, reexports, or transfers to data centers outside of the United States where there is knowledge that a company headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent is headquartered in, Macau or D:5 will be an intended remote end user.",
          "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, preamble, section III.B (released text, pp. 13-14, lines 618-629)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "744.23-a3iA",
          "quotation": "Any item subject to the EAR and specified in ECCN 3A001.z; 3A090 (except for 3A090.c); 4A003.z; 4A004.z; 4A005.z; 4A090; 5A002.z; 5A004.z; 5A992.z, 5D002.z; 5D992.z destined to any destination other than those specified in Country Groups D:1, D:4, or D:5 (excluding any destination also specified in Country Groups A:5 or A:6) for an entity that is headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, either Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5 (e.g., a PRC-headquartered cloud or data server provider located outside of Country Groups D:1, D:4, or D:5 (excluding any destination also specified in Country Groups A:5 or A:6)).",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.23(a)(3)(i)(A) (released text, p. 32, lines 1506-1520)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "ecfr-744.23-a-lead",
          "quotation": "In addition to the license requirements for items specified on the CCL, you may not export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) without a license any item subject to the EAR described in paragraphs (a)(1) through (4) of this section when you have “knowledge” at the time of export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) that the item is destined for a destination, end use, or type of end user described in paragraphs (a)(1) through (4) of this section, unless excluded by paragraph (a)(5) of this section.",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.23(a)",
          "source": "15 CFR 744.23 (eCFR)",
          "document_date": "2026-01-15",
          "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-744/section-744.23",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-lead",
          "quotation": "The following activities may trigger a license requirement under the catch-all controls of part 744 of the EAR when there is “knowledge” (see inset below for further information about “knowledge” under the EAR) that the AI model will be used for a WMD or military-intelligence end use/user:",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-transfer",
          "quotation": "Transfers (in-country), defined as a change in end use or end user, of advanced computing ICs and commodities subject to the EAR already in the possession of parties such as IaaS providers, if there is “knowledge” that the items will be used by the transferee to train AI models for or on behalf of parties headquartered in D:5 countries (including China) or Macau.",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1, second bullet",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "hr2683-def",
          "quotation": "The term `remote access' means access on a purposeful, knowing, reckless, or negligent basis to an item subject to the jurisdiction of the United States under this Act by a foreign person through a network connection, including the internet or a cloud computing service, from a location other than where the item is physically located if the Secretary determines that the use of the item could pose a serious risk to the national security or foreign policy of the United States.",
          "section": "H.R. 2683 (engrossed), sec. 2(1), new ECRA sec. 1742(15)",
          "source": "H.R. 2683 (119th Congress), Engrossed in House (GPO)",
          "document_date": "2026-01-12",
          "url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr2683eh/html/BILLS-119hr2683eh.htm",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:10Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "As lede-2-renting: BIS's statement puts the licence on the chips' export, reexport or transfer, and the control applies only with knowledge. The card names no chip ('Rented abroad from another company’s data centre'), hence 'the chips ... need'. The first clause is rented-today's printed form without 'only', which BIS's statement makes wrong. 'A bill has passed the House' rests on the first reader's reading of H.R. 2683 (engrossed 12 Jan 2026), not rechecked after 14 Nov.",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026"
    },
    {
      "id": "rented-on-publication",
      "sentence": "Also needs one for chips the exporter knows are bound for a data centre that gives or will give companies headquartered in China access to more than 12,000,000 aggregate TPP, unless the access is only for a commercial recommender system and the exporter reports it to BIS; a data centre already supplying them a “significant volume” of compute must obtain one within 90 days to continue.",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN",
      "words_if_changed": null,
      "quotation": "without a license if you have “knowledge” at the time of the export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) that the item is destined to a data center to or within any destination worldwide that is providing or will provide access to more than 12,000,000 “aggregate TPP” either at one data center or through ‘linked data centers’ to or for companies headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5 in supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the EAR.",
      "section": "15 CFR 744.24(a)(1) (released text, p. 33, lines 1580-1592)",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "First screen, rented route's card, under the label \"On publication\"",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "744.24-a1-core",
          "quotation": "without a license if you have “knowledge” at the time of the export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) that the item is destined to a data center to or within any destination worldwide that is providing or will provide access to more than 12,000,000 “aggregate TPP” either at one data center or through ‘linked data centers’ to or for companies headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5 in supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the EAR.",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.24(a)(1) (released text, p. 33, lines 1580-1592)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "744.24-b2-lead",
          "quotation": "The prohibitions under this section do not apply when the computing power access is only being provided for a ‘commercial recommender system’ and you submit the following information to https://www.bis.gov/ai/exclusionnotesubmission, which will be shared with the End User Review Committee.",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.24(b)(2) (released text, p. 35, lines 1682-1688)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "744.24-b3",
          "quotation": "Any data center providing significant volume of compute power to companies headquartered, or with an ultimate parent headquartered, in Macau or Country Group D:5 prior to the publication date of this rule that wishes to continue providing these services must obtain a license with 90 days of the effective date of this IFR or face future export restrictions.",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.24(b)(3) (released text, p. 36, lines 1707-1715)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "744.24-d1-full",
          "quotation": "A commercial recommender system means a Super Intelligence (SI) tool exclusively designed and exclusively used to rank, filter, or suggest commercial products, services, or content to users based on user behavior, transaction history, or item attributes. This term does not include any SI system designed or used to generate novel text, image, audio, video, software, or other content in response to user inputs, or any system that incorporates such model, regardless of whether the system also performs recommendation functions.",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.24(d)(1) (released text, p. 36, lines 1723-1735)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "dates",
          "quotation": "This rule is effective [INSERT DATE OF PUBLICATION IN THE FEDERAL REGISTER].",
          "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, DATES (released text, p. 3, lines 96-98)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "preamble-p4-summary-90d",
          "quotation": "Any data center providing significant volume of compute power to companies headquartered, or with an ultimate parent headquartered, in Macau or Country Group D:5 prior to the publication date of this rule that wishes to continue providing these services must obtain a license with 90 days of the effective date of this IFR or face future export restrictions. However, the license requirement will not apply to ‘commercial recommender systems,’ such as those used by online retailers and social media companies, as these functions do not pose the same national security threat.",
          "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, preamble, section I (released text, p. 5, lines 202-214)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "preamble-p14-recommender",
          "quotation": "Bona fide operators of data centers who are otherwise engaged in activities consistent with the EAR and were providing remote access used for ‘commercial recommender systems’ (as defined in the new § 744.24(d)(1)) may continue providing these services for 90 days, but must obtain a license following expiration of this period to continue these services.",
          "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, preamble, section III.B (released text, p. 14, lines 631-639)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "(b)(2) excludes access 'only being provided for a ‘commercial recommender system’' when 'you submit' the company's name, its aggregate TPP and the due diligence performed (lines 1690-1707) to a bis.gov address; 'the exporter reports it to BIS' compresses that, the 'you' of (a)(1) being whoever exports, reexports or transfers. (b)(3) puts the 90-day licence on 'Any data center ... that wishes to continue providing these services'; 'must obtain one within 90 days to continue' renders it and leaves out, without contradicting, the rule's sanction 'or face future export restrictions', which part 3 prints. 'Already supplying' is within 'prior to the publication date'. The rule's text disagrees with itself on recommender systems: the summary (p. 5) follows the 90-day sentence with 'However, the license requirement will not apply to ‘commercial recommender systems’', while the preamble (p. 14) says recommender-system operators 'may continue providing these services for 90 days, but must obtain a license following expiration of this period'. The sentence follows the operative text, (b)(2) for new exports and (b)(3), which has no carve-out, for existing data centres; p. 14 agrees with it and p. 5 can be read against it. The page should quote p. 14 beside (b)(2).",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026"
    },
    {
      "id": "rented-in-force",
      "sentence": "Since {published}, needs a licence for chips the exporter knows are bound for a data centre that gives or will give companies headquartered in China access to more than 12,000,000 aggregate TPP, unless the access is only for a commercial recommender system and the exporter reports it to BIS; a data centre that supplied them a “significant volume” of compute before then must obtain one within 90 days of {published} to continue.",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN",
      "words_if_changed": null,
      "quotation": "without a license if you have “knowledge” at the time of the export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) that the item is destined to a data center to or within any destination worldwide that is providing or will provide access to more than 12,000,000 “aggregate TPP” either at one data center or through ‘linked data centers’ to or for companies headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5 in supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the EAR.",
      "section": "15 CFR 744.24(a)(1) (released text, p. 33, lines 1580-1592)",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "First screen, rented route's card, first line (no label)",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "744.24-a1-core",
          "quotation": "without a license if you have “knowledge” at the time of the export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) that the item is destined to a data center to or within any destination worldwide that is providing or will provide access to more than 12,000,000 “aggregate TPP” either at one data center or through ‘linked data centers’ to or for companies headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5 in supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the EAR.",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.24(a)(1) (released text, p. 33, lines 1580-1592)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "744.24-b2-lead",
          "quotation": "The prohibitions under this section do not apply when the computing power access is only being provided for a ‘commercial recommender system’ and you submit the following information to https://www.bis.gov/ai/exclusionnotesubmission, which will be shared with the End User Review Committee.",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.24(b)(2) (released text, p. 35, lines 1682-1688)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "744.24-b3",
          "quotation": "Any data center providing significant volume of compute power to companies headquartered, or with an ultimate parent headquartered, in Macau or Country Group D:5 prior to the publication date of this rule that wishes to continue providing these services must obtain a license with 90 days of the effective date of this IFR or face future export restrictions.",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.24(b)(3) (released text, p. 36, lines 1707-1715)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "744.24-d1-full",
          "quotation": "A commercial recommender system means a Super Intelligence (SI) tool exclusively designed and exclusively used to rank, filter, or suggest commercial products, services, or content to users based on user behavior, transaction history, or item attributes. This term does not include any SI system designed or used to generate novel text, image, audio, video, software, or other content in response to user inputs, or any system that incorporates such model, regardless of whether the system also performs recommendation functions.",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.24(d)(1) (released text, p. 36, lines 1723-1735)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "dates",
          "quotation": "This rule is effective [INSERT DATE OF PUBLICATION IN THE FEDERAL REGISTER].",
          "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, DATES (released text, p. 3, lines 96-98)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "preamble-p4-summary-90d",
          "quotation": "Any data center providing significant volume of compute power to companies headquartered, or with an ultimate parent headquartered, in Macau or Country Group D:5 prior to the publication date of this rule that wishes to continue providing these services must obtain a license with 90 days of the effective date of this IFR or face future export restrictions. However, the license requirement will not apply to ‘commercial recommender systems,’ such as those used by online retailers and social media companies, as these functions do not pose the same national security threat.",
          "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, preamble, section I (released text, p. 5, lines 202-214)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "preamble-p14-recommender",
          "quotation": "Bona fide operators of data centers who are otherwise engaged in activities consistent with the EAR and were providing remote access used for ‘commercial recommender systems’ (as defined in the new § 744.24(d)(1)) may continue providing these services for 90 days, but must obtain a license following expiration of this period to continue these services.",
          "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, preamble, section III.B (released text, p. 14, lines 631-639)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "As rented-on-publication, read as a template with 20 Nov 2026 for {published}: 'before then' renders 'prior to the publication date of this rule' and 'within 90 days of {published}' renders 'of the effective date of this IFR', the effective date being the date of publication (DATES). Re-read against the published text at publication.",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026"
    },
    {
      "id": "tick-in-force-rented",
      "sentence": "needs a licence above 12,000,000 aggregate TPP",
      "verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN",
      "words_if_changed": null,
      "quotation": "without a license if you have “knowledge” at the time of the export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) that the item is destined to a data center to or within any destination worldwide that is providing or will provide access to more than 12,000,000 “aggregate TPP” either at one data center or through ‘linked data centers’ to or for companies headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5 in supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the EAR.",
      "section": "15 CFR 744.24(a)(1) (released text, p. 33, lines 1580-1592)",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "where": "Part 2, the rented route's lane: the tick at the publication date (Federal Register citation beside it)",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "744.24-a1-core",
          "quotation": "without a license if you have “knowledge” at the time of the export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) that the item is destined to a data center to or within any destination worldwide that is providing or will provide access to more than 12,000,000 “aggregate TPP” either at one data center or through ‘linked data centers’ to or for companies headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5 in supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the EAR.",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.24(a)(1) (released text, p. 33, lines 1580-1592)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "744.24-b1",
          "quotation": "No license exceptions may overcome the prohibition described in paragraph (a) of this section, except as noted by BIS when a destination is designated under paragraphs (3) of this section.",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.24(b)(1) (released text, p. 35, lines 1676-1680)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "744.24-e",
          "quotation": "For any export, reexport, or transfer made on or after [INSERT DATE OF PUBLICATION IN THE FEDERAL REGISTER] without authorization, i.e., because the exporter, reexporter, or transferor had no “knowledge” that the item is for a prohibited end-use under this section and no other EAR license requirement applies, the exporter, reexporter, or transferor must inform the recipient that a BIS authorization is required if the item or items will be used at a data center to provide access to more than 12,000,000 “aggregate TPP” either at one data center or through ‘linked data centers’ to or for companies headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5 in supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the EAR. The notification from the exporter, reexporter, or transferor must also specify that the transferor, e.g., the data center operator, must obtain authorization for this change in end-use.",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.24(e) (released text, p. 37, lines 1750-1772)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "preamble-change-in-end-use",
          "quotation": "Changes in end-use from a non-prohibited end-use to a prohibited end-use under paragraphs (a)(1) are considered a “transfer (in-country)” for purposes of paragraphs (a)(1) or (2) and require an EAR authorization under § 744.24.",
          "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, preamble, section III.A (released text, p. 12, lines 541-545)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "744.24-b3",
          "quotation": "Any data center providing significant volume of compute power to companies headquartered, or with an ultimate parent headquartered, in Macau or Country Group D:5 prior to the publication date of this rule that wishes to continue providing these services must obtain a license with 90 days of the effective date of this IFR or face future export restrictions.",
          "section": "15 CFR 744.24(b)(3) (released text, p. 36, lines 1707-1715)",
          "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
          "document_date": "2026-11-16",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ],
      "note": "From publication, renting such a company access above the threshold needs a licence on both sides of the arrangement: the exporter's, with knowledge, under (a)(1), and the data centre operator's for its change in end use under (e) ('the transferor, e.g., the data center operator, must obtain authorization for this change in end-use') or, for service begun before publication, (b)(3); no licence exception overcomes the prohibition ((b)(1)). 'Above' renders 'more than'. Like the May 2025 tick, it leaves the conditions to the card.",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026"
    }
  ],
  "rules_in_their_words": [
    {
      "quote_id": "742.6-a6iiiA",
      "quotation": "(iii)(A) Worldwide license requirement. A license is required to export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) items specified in ECCNs 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a; 3A090.a; 3D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, or 3A090.a); 3E001 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, or 3A090.a); 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a; 4A004.z.1; 4A005.z.1; 4A090.a; 4D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, and 4A005.z.1); 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090.a); 4E001 (for commodities controlled by 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, 4A005.z.1, 4A090.a or “software” specified by 4D001 (for 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, or 4A005.z.1), or 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090.a)); 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a; 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a; 5A992.z.1; 5D002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a, z.6.a, z.7.a, z.8.a, and z.9.a; 5D992.z.1; 5E002 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a or 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a or “software” specified by 5D002 (for 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a or 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a commodities)); or 5E992 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A992.z.1 or “software” controlled by 5D992.z.1.) to or within any destination worldwide.",
      "section": "15 CFR 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A)",
      "source": "15 CFR 742.6, Regional stability (eCFR)",
      "document_date": "2026-07-23",
      "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-742/section-742.6",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:47Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "the short form keeps the rule's words in order with \"…\" for the ECCNs left out; every kept piece is in the full quotation",
      "id": "rule-sold-1",
      "route": "sold",
      "label": "Needs a licence",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "quotation_short": "A license is required to export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) items specified in ECCNs … 3A090.a; … 4A090.a; … to or within any destination worldwide.",
      "dated_label": "Needs a licence worldwide, in the eCFR’s text of 23 Jul 2026",
      "dated_label_verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "742.6-b10iiiA1-s1",
      "quotation": "There is a case-by-case license review policy for license applications for exports of commodities with a TPP (as defined in Technical Note 2 to 3A090.a and 3A090.b) less than 21,000, and a 'total DRAM bandwidth' (as defined in the notes to paragraph (dd)(1) in supplement no. 2 to part 748) less than 6,500 GB/s, when destined to end-users located in China or Macau, provided the applicant provides the additional information described in supplement no. 2 to part 748 under paragraph (dd).",
      "section": "15 CFR 742.6(b)(10)(iii)(A)(1)",
      "source": "15 CFR 742.6, Regional stability (eCFR)",
      "document_date": "2026-07-23",
      "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-742/section-742.6",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:47Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "id": "rule-sold-2",
      "route": "sold",
      "label": "Reviewed case by case below a performance line",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "dated_label": "Reviewed case by case below a performance line, in the eCFR’s text of 23 Jul 2026",
      "dated_label_verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "742.6-b10iiiA1-s2",
      "quotation": "All other applications for exports, reexports, or transfers (in-country) will be reviewed under a presumption of denial to or within Macau or destinations specified in Country Group D:5 or to an entity headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, either Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5.",
      "section": "15 CFR 742.6(b)(10)(iii)(A)(1)",
      "source": "15 CFR 742.6, Regional stability (eCFR)",
      "document_date": "2026-07-23",
      "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-742/section-742.6",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:47Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "id": "rule-sold-3",
      "route": "sold",
      "label": "Otherwise presumed denied",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "dated_label": "Otherwise presumed denied, in the eCFR’s text of 23 Jul 2026",
      "dated_label_verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "fr2026-summary",
      "quotation": "The Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) is revising its license review policy for exports of certain semiconductors to China and Macau—changing it from a presumption of denial to a case-by-case review.",
      "section": "91 FR 1684, Summary",
      "source": "91 FR 1684, FR Doc. 2026-00789 (final rule)",
      "document_date": "2026-01-15",
      "url": "https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/01/15/2026-00789/revision-to-license-review-policy-for-advanced-computing-commodities",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:57:56Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "id": "rule-sold-4",
      "route": "sold",
      "label": "Changed on 15 Jan 2026",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "fr2026-kyc",
      "quotation": "the ultimate consignee will employ rigorous Know Your Customer (KYC) procedures to screen and prevent unauthorized remote access to unauthorized parties (e.g., prohibited part 744 parties);",
      "section": "91 FR 1684, section I (one item of a list the applicant must certify)",
      "source": "91 FR 1684, FR Doc. 2026-00789 (final rule)",
      "document_date": "2026-01-15",
      "url": "https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/01/15/2026-00789/revision-to-license-review-policy-for-advanced-computing-commodities",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:57:56Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "a list item, quoted from its first word; the XML puts formatting whitespace between \"(\" and the italic \"e.g.,\", removed here as the printed rule reads",
      "id": "rule-sold-5",
      "route": "sold",
      "label": "A licence condition on remote access",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "742.6-a6iiiA",
      "quotation": "(iii)(A) Worldwide license requirement. A license is required to export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) items specified in ECCNs 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a; 3A090.a; 3D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, or 3A090.a); 3E001 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, or 3A090.a); 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a; 4A004.z.1; 4A005.z.1; 4A090.a; 4D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, and 4A005.z.1); 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090.a); 4E001 (for commodities controlled by 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, 4A005.z.1, 4A090.a or “software” specified by 4D001 (for 4A003.z.1.a, z.2.a, 4A004.z.1, or 4A005.z.1), or 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090.a)); 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a; 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a; 5A992.z.1; 5D002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a, z.6.a, z.7.a, z.8.a, and z.9.a; 5D992.z.1; 5E002 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a or 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a or “software” specified by 5D002 (for 5A002.z.1.a, z.2.a, z.3.a, z.4.a, z.5.a or 5A004.z.1.a, z.2.a commodities)); or 5E992 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A992.z.1 or “software” controlled by 5D992.z.1.) to or within any destination worldwide.",
      "section": "15 CFR 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A)",
      "source": "15 CFR 742.6, Regional stability (eCFR)",
      "document_date": "2026-07-23",
      "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-742/section-742.6",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:47Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "id": "rule-moved-1",
      "route": "moved",
      "label": "Needs a licence",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "quotation_short": "A license is required to export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) items specified in ECCNs … 3A090.a; … 4A090.a; … to or within any destination worldwide.",
      "dated_label": "Needs a licence worldwide, in the eCFR’s text of 23 Jul 2026",
      "dated_label_verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "fr2022-a6i",
      "quotation": "A license is required for items specified in ECCNs 3A090, 3B090, 4A090, 5A992 (that meet or exceed the performance parameters of ECCNs 3A090 or 4A090) and associated software and technology in 3D001 (for 3A090 or 3B090), 3E001 (for 3A090 or 3B090), 3B090, or 3D001 (for 3A090 or 3B090), 4D090, 4E001 (for 4A090 and 4D090), and 5D992 (that meet or exceed the performance parameters of ECCNs 3A090 or 4A090) being exported, reexported, or transferred (in-country) to or within the China.",
      "section": "87 FR 62186, § 742.6(a)(6)(i) as added (effective 7 Oct 2022)",
      "source": "87 FR 62186, FR Doc. 2022-21658 (interim final rule)",
      "document_date": "2022-10-13",
      "url": "https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/10/13/2022-21658/implementation-of-additional-export-controls-certain-advanced-computing-and-semiconductor",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:58:12Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "the rule's own words, including \"to or within the China\"",
      "id": "rule-moved-2",
      "route": "moved",
      "label": "Needed one from 7 Oct 2022",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "guidance-s1",
      "quotation": "The Department of Commerce, Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) is issuing this guidance to clarify that a license is required to export advanced computing items to entities headquartered in Country Group D:5 (see supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the Export Administration Regulations (EAR) (15 CFR parts 730-774)) or Macau or with an ultimate parent company headquartered in Country Group D:5 or Macau – even if the entities themselves are located outside Country Group D:5 or Macau.",
      "section": "BIS guidance of 31 May 2026, para. 1",
      "source": "BIS, Guidance Regarding Enforcement of License Requirements for Advanced Computing Items for Entities Headquartered in Country Group D:5 and Macau [May 31, 2026]",
      "document_date": "2026-05-31",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/bis-guidance-may-31-2026.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:38Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "id": "rule-bought-1",
      "route": "bought",
      "label": "Needs a licence, wherever the buyer is",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "guidance-first",
      "quotation": "This license requirement was first introduced on November 17, 2023. It was implemented via an end-user control in § 744.23(a)(3) of the EAR and applied to all advanced computing items (e.g., those specified in Export Control Classification Numbers (ECCNs) 3A090.a and .b, 4A090.a and .b, and related .z paragraph items).",
      "section": "BIS guidance of 31 May 2026, para. 2",
      "source": "BIS, Guidance Regarding Enforcement of License Requirements for Advanced Computing Items for Entities Headquartered in Country Group D:5 and Macau [May 31, 2026]",
      "document_date": "2026-05-31",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/bis-guidance-may-31-2026.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:38Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "id": "rule-bought-2",
      "route": "bought",
      "label": "Since 17 Nov 2023",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "fr2023-why",
      "quotation": "This additional end-use control is needed to ensure that the national security objectives of the October 7 IFR and this AC/S IFR are not undermined by Macau, PRC or other Country Group D:5 entities setting up cloud or data servers in other countries to allow these headquartered companies of concern to continue to train their AI models in ways that would be contrary to U.S. national security interests.",
      "section": "88 FR 73458, preamble on § 744.23(a)(3)(i)",
      "source": "88 FR 73458, FR Doc. 2023-23055 (interim final rule)",
      "document_date": "2023-10-25",
      "url": "https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/10/25/2023-23055/implementation-of-additional-export-controls-certain-advanced-computing-items-supercomputer-and",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:57:54Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "id": "rule-bought-3",
      "route": "bought",
      "label": "BIS’s reason for adding it",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "guidance-dc",
      "quotation": "Bona fide operators of data centers who are otherwise engaged in activities consistent with the EAR are not required to cease the ongoing use, storage, disposal, or servicing of advanced computing items because of this guidance, until further notice from BIS.",
      "section": "BIS guidance of 31 May 2026, para. 4",
      "source": "BIS, Guidance Regarding Enforcement of License Requirements for Advanced Computing Items for Entities Headquartered in Country Group D:5 and Macau [May 31, 2026]",
      "document_date": "2026-05-31",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/bis-guidance-may-31-2026.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:38Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "id": "rule-bought-4",
      "route": "bought",
      "label": "Chips already installed may keep running",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "dated_label": "Chips already installed could keep running until further notice, BIS said on 31 May 2026",
      "dated_label_verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "ao2009",
      "quotation": "The service of providing computational capacity would not be subject to the EAR as the service provider is not shipping or transmitting any commodity, software, or technology to the user.",
      "section": "BIS Advisory Opinion, 13 Jan 2009, p. 2, answer (1)",
      "source": "BIS Advisory Opinion of 13 Jan 2009 on grid and cloud computing services (scanned letter)",
      "document_date": "2009-01-13",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/1343",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:35Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "read from the page image of p. 2 (rendered from the saved PDF); the PDF's character-recognition layer prints \"thc\", \"scrvicc\" and \"uscr\" for \"the\", \"service\" and \"user\"",
      "id": "rule-rented-1",
      "route": "rented",
      "label": "Does not need one",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "dated_label": "Outside the rules, BIS advised in 2009",
      "dated_label_verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "policy2025-lead",
      "quotation": "The following activities may trigger a license requirement under the catch-all controls of part 744 of the EAR when there is “knowledge” (see inset below for further information about “knowledge” under the EAR) that the AI model will be used for a WMD or military-intelligence end use/user:",
      "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1",
      "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
      "document_date": "2025-05-13",
      "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "bis.gov's file of 13 Oct 2026 prints \"SI model\" here; the 13 May 2025 file prints \"AI model\"",
      "id": "rule-rented-2",
      "route": "rented",
      "label": "May need one under the catch-all",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "dated_label": "May need one under the catch-all, BIS said in May 2025",
      "dated_label_verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "policy2025-transfer",
      "quotation": "Transfers (in-country), defined as a change in end use or end user, of advanced computing ICs and commodities subject to the EAR already in the possession of parties such as IaaS providers, if there is “knowledge” that the items will be used by the transferee to train AI models for or on behalf of parties headquartered in D:5 countries (including China) or Macau.",
      "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1, second bullet",
      "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
      "document_date": "2025-05-13",
      "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "bis.gov's file of 13 Oct 2026 prints \"SI models\" here",
      "id": "rule-rented-3",
      "route": "rented",
      "label": "Covers chips already in a data centre",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "dated_label": "The catch-all reaches chips already in a data centre, BIS said in May 2025",
      "dated_label_verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "policy2025-entitylist",
      "quotation": "foreign parties acting contrary to U.S. national security and foreign policy interests, including by training AI models that could support WMD or military-intelligence end uses for or on behalf of parties headquartered in Country Group D:5 (including China) or Macau, may be added to the Entity List, even where no violation of the EAR occurs.",
      "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 2",
      "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
      "document_date": "2025-05-13",
      "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "the sentence begins \"In addition,\" on p. 1; quoted from its subject. bis.gov's file of 13 Oct 2026 prints \"SI models\" here",
      "id": "rule-rented-4",
      "route": "rented",
      "label": "A listing needs no violation",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "printed_label": "A listing does not need a violation",
      "printed_label_verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN",
      "printed_label_note": "The quoted sentence: foreign parties \"may be added to the Entity List, even where no violation of the EAR occurs\". The label keeps \"may\" by saying what a listing does not need, not that one follows."
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "hr2683-def",
      "quotation": "The term `remote access' means access on a purposeful, knowing, reckless, or negligent basis to an item subject to the jurisdiction of the United States under this Act by a foreign person through a network connection, including the internet or a cloud computing service, from a location other than where the item is physically located if the Secretary determines that the use of the item could pose a serious risk to the national security or foreign policy of the United States.",
      "section": "H.R. 2683 (engrossed), sec. 2(1), new ECRA sec. 1742(15)",
      "source": "H.R. 2683 (119th Congress), Engrossed in House (GPO)",
      "document_date": "2026-01-12",
      "url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr2683eh/html/BILLS-119hr2683eh.htm",
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:10Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "a bill, not law; passed the House 12 Jan 2026, referred to Senate Banking 13 Jan 2026",
      "id": "rule-rented-5",
      "route": "rented",
      "label": "A bill that passed the House would let Commerce control it",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "dated_label": "A bill that passed the House on 12 Jan 2026 would let Commerce control remote access",
      "dated_label_verdict": "SUPPORTED AS WRITTEN"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "744.24-a1-core",
      "quotation": "without a license if you have “knowledge” at the time of the export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) that the item is destined to a data center to or within any destination worldwide that is providing or will provide access to more than 12,000,000 “aggregate TPP” either at one data center or through ‘linked data centers’ to or for companies headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5 in supplement no. 1 to part 740 of the EAR.",
      "section": "15 CFR 744.24(a)(1)",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "Cut by the second reader from the released text, p. 33, lines 1580-1592; equal to the builder's copy, character for character.",
      "id": "rule-rented-6",
      "route": "rented",
      "label": "The requirement, above 12,000,000 aggregate TPP",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "released_rule": true,
      "released_pages": "p. 33"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "744.24-b2-lead",
      "quotation": "The prohibitions under this section do not apply when the computing power access is only being provided for a ‘commercial recommender system’ and you submit the following information to https://www.bis.gov/ai/exclusionnotesubmission, which will be shared with the End User Review Committee.",
      "section": "15 CFR 744.24(b)(2)",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "Cut by the second reader from the released text, p. 35, lines 1682-1688; equal to the builder's copy, character for character. The information to be submitted, (i) to (iii), follows at lines 1690-1707.",
      "id": "rule-rented-7",
      "route": "rented",
      "label": "The exclusion for commercial recommender systems",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "released_rule": true,
      "released_pages": "p. 35"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "744.24-d1-first",
      "quotation": "A commercial recommender system means a Super Intelligence (SI) tool exclusively designed and exclusively used to rank, filter, or suggest commercial products, services, or content to users based on user behavior, transaction history, or item attributes.",
      "section": "15 CFR 744.24(d)(1)",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "Cut by the second reader from the released text, p. 36, lines 1723-1729; equal to the builder's copy, character for character. The label says 'as the rule defines it' over the first sentence only; the second (lines 1729-1735) excludes generative systems and 'any system that incorporates such model, regardless of whether the system also performs recommendation functions'. Quote both sentences or narrow the label.",
      "id": "rule-rented-8",
      "route": "rented",
      "label": "The first sentence of the rule’s definition of a commercial recommender system",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "released_rule": true,
      "released_pages": "p. 36"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "744.24-b3",
      "quotation": "Any data center providing significant volume of compute power to companies headquartered, or with an ultimate parent headquartered, in Macau or Country Group D:5 prior to the publication date of this rule that wishes to continue providing these services must obtain a license with 90 days of the effective date of this IFR or face future export restrictions.",
      "section": "15 CFR 744.24(b)(3)",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "Cut by the second reader from the released text, p. 36, lines 1707-1715; equal to the builder's copy, character for character. 'with 90 days' is the released text's own wording. After publication 'already' in the label reads as of the reader's day; the paragraph means 'prior to the publication date of this rule' ('before publication' would say so).",
      "id": "rule-rented-9",
      "route": "rented",
      "label": "Data centres supplying such companies before publication",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "released_rule": true,
      "released_pages": "p. 36"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "744.24-note3-redflag",
      "quotation": "A foreign data center declining or being unable to provide information sufficient to verify compliance with this end use control shall be considered a red flag that presumptively provides you with “knowledge” unless you are able to resolve that red flag before proceeding with the transaction.",
      "section": "Note 3 to 15 CFR 744.24(a)(1)",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "Cut by the second reader from the released text, p. 34, lines 1631-1637; equal to the builder's copy, character for character.",
      "id": "rule-rented-10",
      "route": "rented",
      "label": "A red flag for the exporter",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "released_rule": true,
      "released_pages": "p. 34"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "744.24-d2",
      "quotation": "For purposes of this section, a ‘linked data center’ means a data center that uses networking infrastructure that links two or more separate data centers together, through digitally-linked or physically-linked infrastructure, that allows physical and virtual facilities to share resources, balance workloads, and replicate data as a unified whole. ‘Linked data center’ includes digitally-linked infrastructure, not just physically-linked infrastructure.",
      "section": "15 CFR 744.24(d)(2)",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "Cut by the second reader from the released text, p. 36, lines 1737-1745; equal to the builder's copy, character for character.",
      "id": "rule-rented-11",
      "route": "rented",
      "label": "Linked data centres",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "released_rule": true,
      "released_pages": "p. 36"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "preamble-744.23-on-behalf",
      "quotation": "This end-use control thus is not, and has never been limited only to exports, reexports, and transfers (in-country) destined to such entities of concern as ultimate consignees or end users, but extends to exports, reexports, or transfers (in-country) on behalf of these entities of concern, e.g., if an entity of concern was the purchaser in the transaction (directly or indirectly) or was the exclusive or primary (greater than 50 percent of total compute) remote end user of the data center computing capacity.",
      "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, preamble, section III.B",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "Cut by the second reader from the released text, p. 13, lines 606-618; equal to the builder's copy, character for character. Section corrected from 'section I.B': the passage is under 'III. End-Use Restrictions' (line 340), 'B. Conforming change to 744.23 ...' (line 547). The label's 2023 control: 'As stated in BIS’s October 2023 Advanced Computing/Supercomputing (“AC/S”) IFR (88 FR 73458)' (lines 594-596).",
      "id": "rule-rented-12",
      "route": "rented",
      "label": "BIS’s reading of its 2023 control",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "released_rule": true,
      "released_pages": "p. 13"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "742.6-a6iiiA-released",
      "quotation": "A license is required for items specified in ECCNs 3A001.z; 3A090 (except for 3A090.c); 3D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z, 3A090 (except for 3A090.c)); 3E001 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z, 3A090 (except for 3A090.c)); 4A003.z; 4A004.z; 4A005.z; 4A090; 4D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A003.z, 4A004.z, and 4A005.z); 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090); 4E001 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 4A003.z, 4A004.z, 4A005.z, 4A090 or “software” specified by 4D001 (for 4A003.z, 4A004.z, and 4A005.z), 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090)); 5A002.z; 5A004.z; 5A992.z; 5D002.z; 5D992.z; 5E002 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A002.z or 5A004.z or “software” specified by 5D002 (for 5A002.z or 5A004.z commodities)); or 5E992 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A992.z or “software” controlled by 5D992.z) for exports, reexports, and transfers (in-country) to or within the destinations specified under paragraphs (a)(6)(iii)(A)(1)-(2).",
      "section": "15 CFR 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A)",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "Cut by the second reader from the released text, pp. 26-27, lines 1254-1279; equal to the builder's copy, character for character. The rule revises § 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A) (amendatory instruction a, line 1230).",
      "id": "rule-sold-6",
      "route": "sold",
      "label": "The requirement as the rule revises it, by destination",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "released_rule": true,
      "released_pages": "pp. 26-27"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "742.6-a6iiiA2-released",
      "quotation": "A destination in Country Groups D:1, D:4, or D:5 (excluding destinations also specified in Country Groups A:5 or A:6) or the United Arab Emirates, except that a license is not required when the ultimate consignee and all end users are approved entities in the United Arab Emirates listed in supplement no. 8 to part 740 and specified as approved to receive the items covered by this paragraph.",
      "section": "15 CFR 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A)(2)",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "Cut by the second reader from the released text, p. 27, lines 1295-1303; equal to the builder's copy, character for character. The label leaves out the United Arab Emirates, which the paragraph names, with an exception for approved UAE entities. The PRC is among D:5 (preamble, line 600).",
      "id": "rule-sold-7",
      "route": "sold",
      "label": "Destinations in Country Groups D:1, D:4 and D:5, which include China, and the United Arab Emirates",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "released_rule": true,
      "released_pages": "p. 27"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "742.6-a6iiiA-released",
      "quotation": "A license is required for items specified in ECCNs 3A001.z; 3A090 (except for 3A090.c); 3D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z, 3A090 (except for 3A090.c)); 3E001 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 3A001.z, 3A090 (except for 3A090.c)); 4A003.z; 4A004.z; 4A005.z; 4A090; 4D001 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A003.z, 4A004.z, and 4A005.z); 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090); 4E001 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 4A003.z, 4A004.z, 4A005.z, 4A090 or “software” specified by 4D001 (for 4A003.z, 4A004.z, and 4A005.z), 4D090 (for “software” for commodities controlled by 4A090)); 5A002.z; 5A004.z; 5A992.z; 5D002.z; 5D992.z; 5E002 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A002.z or 5A004.z or “software” specified by 5D002 (for 5A002.z or 5A004.z commodities)); or 5E992 (for “technology” for commodities controlled by 5A992.z or “software” controlled by 5D992.z) for exports, reexports, and transfers (in-country) to or within the destinations specified under paragraphs (a)(6)(iii)(A)(1)-(2).",
      "section": "15 CFR 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A)",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "Cut by the second reader from the released text, pp. 26-27, lines 1254-1279; equal to the builder's copy, character for character. The rule revises § 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A) (amendatory instruction a, line 1230).",
      "id": "rule-moved-3",
      "route": "moved",
      "label": "The requirement as the rule revises it, by destination",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "released_rule": true,
      "released_pages": "pp. 26-27"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "742.6-a6iiiA2-released",
      "quotation": "A destination in Country Groups D:1, D:4, or D:5 (excluding destinations also specified in Country Groups A:5 or A:6) or the United Arab Emirates, except that a license is not required when the ultimate consignee and all end users are approved entities in the United Arab Emirates listed in supplement no. 8 to part 740 and specified as approved to receive the items covered by this paragraph.",
      "section": "15 CFR 742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A)(2)",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "Cut by the second reader from the released text, p. 27, lines 1295-1303; equal to the builder's copy, character for character. The label leaves out the United Arab Emirates, which the paragraph names, with an exception for approved UAE entities. The PRC is among D:5 (preamble, line 600).",
      "id": "rule-moved-4",
      "route": "moved",
      "label": "Destinations in Country Groups D:1, D:4 and D:5, which include China, and the United Arab Emirates",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "released_rule": true,
      "released_pages": "p. 27"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "744.23-a3iA",
      "quotation": "Any item subject to the EAR and specified in ECCN 3A001.z; 3A090 (except for 3A090.c); 4A003.z; 4A004.z; 4A005.z; 4A090; 5A002.z; 5A004.z; 5A992.z, 5D002.z; 5D992.z destined to any destination other than those specified in Country Groups D:1, D:4, or D:5 (excluding any destination also specified in Country Groups A:5 or A:6) for an entity that is headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, either Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5 (e.g., a PRC-headquartered cloud or data server provider located outside of Country Groups D:1, D:4, or D:5 (excluding any destination also specified in Country Groups A:5 or A:6)).",
      "section": "15 CFR 744.23(a)(3)(i)(A)",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "Cut by the second reader from the released text, p. 32, lines 1506-1520; equal to the builder's copy, character for character. In force today the paragraph names only the .b items (3A090.b, 4A090.b, ...; eCFR § 744.23(a)(3)(i)(A)); the rule widens it to all of 3A090 except 3A090.c.",
      "id": "rule-bought-5",
      "route": "bought",
      "label": "The requirement as the rule revises it",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "released_rule": true,
      "released_pages": "p. 32"
    },
    {
      "quote_id": "preamble-744.23-conforming",
      "quotation": "As a conforming change, this IFR makes revisions to the advanced computing items end-use control under § 744.23(a)(3) to ensure that a license will continue to be required for exports, reexports, and transfers (in-country) of these advanced computing items when such items are destined for entities headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, Country Group D:5 or Macau.",
      "section": "RIN 0694-AK50, preamble, section III.B",
      "source": "RIN 0694-AK50, Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, text released 16 Nov 2026",
      "document_date": "2026-11-16",
      "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/rin-0694-ak50.pdf",
      "read_at": "2026-11-16T18:28:49Z",
      "authority_tier": 1,
      "note": "Cut by the second reader from the released text, p. 12, lines 551-559; equal to the builder's copy, character for character. Section corrected from 'section I.B' to 'section III.B', as rule-rented-12.",
      "id": "rule-bought-6",
      "route": "bought",
      "label": "BIS on keeping the requirement for companies headquartered in China",
      "verdict": "QUOTED EXACTLY",
      "released_rule": true,
      "released_pages": "p. 12"
    }
  ],
  "open_items": [
    {
      "id": "open-miti",
      "question": "MITI's June 2025 statement: an official statement, or a press report of one?",
      "answer": "An official statement. The ministry published it itself as a press release on its own site, dated and signed \"MINISTRY OF INVESTMENT, TRADE AND INDUSTRY 18 June 2025\" (tier 1, 18 Jun 2025). Malay Mail's article of the same day, which Diversion Cases' row cites, is a press report of it, carried from Bernama (tier 3). The register's row (my-miti-20250618-zero-tolerance-statement) quotes the press release and could not reach miti.gov.my on 8 Oct 2026; today the PDF opened, and its first two paragraphs match the register's quotations word for word. By the page's grades the release is an official body's document, and Malay Mail's article a press report of it.",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "miti-p1",
          "quotation": "In reference to a few media reports on the use of servers equipped with Nvidia chips and AI chips in Large Language Models (LLM) training in Malaysia by a Chinese company, the Ministry of Investment, Trade and Industry (MITI) is still in the process of verifying the matter with relevant agencies if any domestic law or regulation has been breached.",
          "section": "MITI press release, para. 1",
          "source": "MITI (Malaysia), press release headed \"ZERO TOLERANCE FOR INDIVIDUALS OR COMPANIES INVOLVED IN ILLEGAL OPERATIONS AND TRADING ACTIVITIES IN MALAYSIA\"",
          "document_date": "2025-06-18",
          "url": "https://www.miti.gov.my/miti/resources/Media%20Release/%5BFINAL%5D_MITI_Press_Release_Zero_Tolerance_for_Breaking_Malaysian_Laws_2025-06-18.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:03:32Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "miti-p2",
          "quotation": "We would like to reiterate that servers using Nvidia chips and AI chips are not classified as controlled goods under the Malaysian Strategic Trade Act 2010 (STA 2010).",
          "section": "MITI press release, para. 2",
          "source": "MITI (Malaysia), press release headed \"ZERO TOLERANCE FOR INDIVIDUALS OR COMPANIES INVOLVED IN ILLEGAL OPERATIONS AND TRADING ACTIVITIES IN MALAYSIA\"",
          "document_date": "2025-06-18",
          "url": "https://www.miti.gov.my/miti/resources/Media%20Release/%5BFINAL%5D_MITI_Press_Release_Zero_Tolerance_for_Breaking_Malaysian_Laws_2025-06-18.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:03:32Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "miti-sign",
          "quotation": "MINISTRY OF INVESTMENT, TRADE AND INDUSTRY 18 June 2025",
          "section": "MITI press release, signature",
          "source": "MITI (Malaysia), press release headed \"ZERO TOLERANCE FOR INDIVIDUALS OR COMPANIES INVOLVED IN ILLEGAL OPERATIONS AND TRADING ACTIVITIES IN MALAYSIA\"",
          "document_date": "2025-06-18",
          "url": "https://www.miti.gov.my/miti/resources/Media%20Release/%5BFINAL%5D_MITI_Press_Release_Zero_Tolerance_for_Breaking_Malaysian_Laws_2025-06-18.pdf",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:03:32Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "malaymail-p",
          "quotation": "In a statement today, MITI said that servers using Nvidia chips and AI chips are not classified as controlled goods under the Malaysian Strategic Trade Act 2010 (STA 2010).",
          "section": "Malay Mail, 18 Jun 2025",
          "source": "Malay Mail, 18 Jun 2025, carrying Bernama",
          "document_date": "2025-06-18",
          "url": "https://www.malaymail.com/news/money/2025/06/18/miti-reviewing-trade-compliance-probing-chinese-firms-alleged-use-of-nvidia-ai-chips-in-malaysia-amid-export-control-concerns/180816",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:03:48Z",
          "authority_tier": 3
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "malaymail-bernama",
          "quotation": "to avoid any secondary sanctions on their businesses. — Bernama",
          "section": "Malay Mail, 18 Jun 2025, last line",
          "source": "Malay Mail, 18 Jun 2025, carrying Bernama",
          "document_date": "2025-06-18",
          "url": "https://www.malaymail.com/news/money/2025/06/18/miti-reviewing-trade-compliance-probing-chinese-firms-alleged-use-of-nvidia-ai-chips-in-malaysia-amid-export-control-concerns/180816",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:03:48Z",
          "authority_tier": 3
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "open-supplier-knows",
      "question": "The source for the wording \"licence if the supplier knows\".",
      "answer": "BIS's policy statement of 13 May 2025, p. 1: the sentence that says the listed activities \"may trigger a license requirement under the catch-all controls of part 744 of the EAR when there is “knowledge” ... that the AI model will be used for a WMD or military-intelligence end use/user\", and its second bullet, which reaches IaaS providers that already hold the chips. Neither version of the statement says \"supplier\"; the drawer's five words condense those two passages (see tick-2025-05). The file bis.gov serves today (created 13 Oct 2026) prints \"SI\" for \"AI\" in the title and in every passage; the 13 May 2025 file, read through the Internet Archive, prints \"AI\", and nothing else in the text differs. The site register's title (\"AI Models\") matches the 2025 file.",
      "passages": [
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-lead",
          "quotation": "The following activities may trigger a license requirement under the catch-all controls of part 744 of the EAR when there is “knowledge” (see inset below for further information about “knowledge” under the EAR) that the AI model will be used for a WMD or military-intelligence end use/user:",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "policy-lead",
          "quotation": "The following activities may trigger a license requirement under the catch-all controls of part 744 of the EAR when there is “knowledge” (see inset below for further information about “knowledge” under the EAR) that the SI model will be used for a WMD or military-intelligence end use/user:",
          "section": "the same sentence as bis.gov serves it on 14 Nov 2026",
          "source": "The same statement as bis.gov serves it on 14 Nov 2026 (title and text print \"SI\" where the 2025 file prints \"AI\")",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:59:12Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        },
        {
          "quote_id": "policy2025-transfer",
          "quotation": "Transfers (in-country), defined as a change in end use or end user, of advanced computing ICs and commodities subject to the EAR already in the possession of parties such as IaaS providers, if there is “knowledge” that the items will be used by the transferee to train AI models for or on behalf of parties headquartered in D:5 countries (including China) or Macau.",
          "section": "BIS policy statement, 13 May 2025, p. 1, second bullet",
          "source": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
          "document_date": "2025-05-13",
          "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
          "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z",
          "authority_tier": 1
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "not_opened": [
    {
      "what": "congress.gov actions page for H.R. 2683",
      "tried": "curl (HTTP 403, Cloudflare page) and /usr/bin/nscurl (\"Just a moment...\" challenge page)",
      "effect": "none: the actions were read from the Library of Congress bill-status XML on govinfo, the engrossed text and the Clerk's roll call"
    },
    {
      "what": "eCFR section pages at www.ecfr.gov/current/...",
      "tried": "curl: HTTP 200 with a \"Request Access\" page",
      "effect": "none for the text, read through the eCFR versioner API; the human links in `url` are the eCFR's standard section addresses and were not opened by me"
    }
  ],
  "sources": {
    "ecfr742.6": {
      "title": "15 CFR 742.6, Regional stability (eCFR)",
      "link": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-742/section-742.6",
      "document_date": "2026-07-23",
      "tier": 1,
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:47Z"
    },
    "ecfr744.23": {
      "title": "15 CFR 744.23 (eCFR)",
      "link": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-744/section-744.23",
      "document_date": "2026-01-15",
      "tier": 1,
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:49Z"
    },
    "ecfr734.13": {
      "title": "15 CFR 734.13, Export (eCFR)",
      "link": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-734/section-734.13",
      "document_date": "2017-01-03",
      "tier": 1,
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:56:54Z"
    },
    "ecfr744.22": {
      "title": "15 CFR 744.22, military-intelligence end uses or end users (eCFR)",
      "link": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-744/section-744.22",
      "document_date": null,
      "tier": 1,
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:04:12Z"
    },
    "fr2022": {
      "title": "87 FR 62186, FR Doc. 2022-21658 (interim final rule)",
      "link": "https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/10/13/2022-21658/implementation-of-additional-export-controls-certain-advanced-computing-and-semiconductor",
      "document_date": "2022-10-13",
      "tier": 1,
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:58:12Z"
    },
    "fr2023": {
      "title": "88 FR 73458, FR Doc. 2023-23055 (interim final rule)",
      "link": "https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/10/25/2023-23055/implementation-of-additional-export-controls-certain-advanced-computing-items-supercomputer-and",
      "document_date": "2023-10-25",
      "tier": 1,
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:57:54Z"
    },
    "fr2026": {
      "title": "91 FR 1684, FR Doc. 2026-00789 (final rule)",
      "link": "https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/01/15/2026-00789/revision-to-license-review-policy-for-advanced-computing-commodities",
      "document_date": "2026-01-15",
      "tier": 1,
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:57:56Z"
    },
    "policy2025": {
      "title": "BIS Policy Statement on Controls that May Apply to Advanced Computing Integrated Circuits and Other Commodities Used to Train AI Models (13 May 2025 file, Internet Archive capture 2025-05-13 22:04:41 UTC)",
      "link": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250513220441id_/https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
      "link_bis_today": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
      "document_date": "2025-05-13",
      "tier": 1,
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:09:31Z"
    },
    "policy": {
      "title": "The same statement as bis.gov serves it on 14 Nov 2026 (title and text print \"SI\" where the 2025 file prints \"AI\")",
      "link": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/ai-policy-statement-training-ai-models-may-13-2025",
      "document_date": "2025-05-13",
      "tier": 1,
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T18:59:12Z"
    },
    "guidance": {
      "title": "BIS, Guidance Regarding Enforcement of License Requirements for Advanced Computing Items for Entities Headquartered in Country Group D:5 and Macau [May 31, 2026]",
      "link": "https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/bis-guidance-may-31-2026.pdf",
      "document_date": "2026-05-31",
      "tier": 1,
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:38Z"
    },
    "ao2009": {
      "title": "BIS Advisory Opinion of 13 Jan 2009 on grid and cloud computing services (scanned letter)",
      "link": "https://www.bis.gov/media/1343",
      "document_date": "2009-01-13",
      "tier": 1,
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:35Z"
    },
    "hr2683eh": {
      "title": "H.R. 2683 (119th Congress), Engrossed in House (GPO)",
      "link": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr2683eh/html/BILLS-119hr2683eh.htm",
      "document_date": "2026-01-12",
      "tier": 1,
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:10Z"
    },
    "billstatus": {
      "title": "BILLSTATUS-119hr2683.xml (Library of Congress bill status, on govinfo)",
      "link": "https://www.govinfo.gov/bulkdata/BILLSTATUS/119/hr/BILLSTATUS-119hr2683.xml",
      "document_date": "2026-01-15",
      "tier": 1,
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:00:42Z"
    },
    "roll013": {
      "title": "Clerk of the House, roll call 13, 119th Congress 2nd session",
      "link": "https://clerk.house.gov/evs/2026/roll013.xml",
      "document_date": "2026-01-12",
      "tier": 1,
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:01:10Z"
    },
    "nvda8k": {
      "title": "NVIDIA Corporation, Form 8-K (Item 8.01), filed 15 Apr 2025, accession 0001045810-25-000082",
      "link": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1045810/000104581025000082/nvda-20250409.htm",
      "document_date": "2025-04-15",
      "tier": 1,
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:03:15Z"
    },
    "miti": {
      "title": "MITI (Malaysia), press release headed \"ZERO TOLERANCE FOR INDIVIDUALS OR COMPANIES INVOLVED IN ILLEGAL OPERATIONS AND TRADING ACTIVITIES IN MALAYSIA\"",
      "link": "https://www.miti.gov.my/miti/resources/Media%20Release/%5BFINAL%5D_MITI_Press_Release_Zero_Tolerance_for_Breaking_Malaysian_Laws_2025-06-18.pdf",
      "document_date": "2025-06-18",
      "tier": 1,
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:03:32Z"
    },
    "malaymail": {
      "title": "Malay Mail, 18 Jun 2025, carrying Bernama",
      "link": "https://www.malaymail.com/news/money/2025/06/18/miti-reviewing-trade-compliance-probing-chinese-firms-alleged-use-of-nvidia-ai-chips-in-malaysia-amid-export-control-concerns/180816",
      "document_date": "2025-06-18",
      "tier": 3,
      "read_at": "2026-11-14T19:03:48Z"
    }
  },
  "left_out": [
    ".sentences[3].note"
  ]
}
